Feed on
Posts
Comments

Our plans for a nostalgic Arsenal interlull have been rather overtaken by events following Friday’s initial announcement about the commission’s verdict on Manchester City’s 115 ( or possibly more) charges. It has provoked huge debate around the football world, albeit a rather uneven debate. Some of the calls I have heard broadcast from C114y fans have bordered on the farcical. One caller suggested this was a massacre of the Manchester populace akin to Peterloo! One challenged Andy Goldstein to tell him one thing that C114y had done wrong, seemingly not realising that they had been handed down a verdict that found them guilty of almost every charge; charges that were around three years old. Another suggested that “We will do what we always do – circle the wagons and win the title,” all delivered in charmless Mancunian tones with a cynical cackle to boot. 

So, where are we and what might this mean for football and what might it mean for Arsenal? This is a summary of what the Premier League released on Monday in a redacted report of the findings of an independent commission. 

The Findings of the Commission 

The independent Commission appointed to hear the Premier League’s case against Manchester City has found the club guilty of all the charges relating to serious breaches of the League’s financial rules over nine seasons, from 2009-10 to 2017-18. It also found City guilty of three of the four charges relating to its alleged failure to co-operate with the Premier League’s investigation. 

The case arose from 115 charges brought by the Premier League in February 2023. The allegations covered two broad areas. The first concerned the accuracy of Manchester City’s financial reporting, particularly revenue from sponsorship agreements, operating costs and related-party transactions. The second concerned alleged failures by the club to assist the Premier League’s subsequent investigation. 

The Commission’s central finding is that City used a series of ‘sham’ commercial contracts which did not represent the true financial arrangements between the parties. According to the Premier League’s account of the findings, these arrangements artificially increased the club’s reported revenues and reduced its reported costs. Some sponsors were apparently required to contribute only a small part of the amounts recorded in their contracts, with the club’s ownership group, Abu Dhabi United Group (ADUG), supplying the much larger balance. 

The effect, according to the Commission, was substantial. Had the arrangements been recorded accurately, Manchester City would have exceeded both the Premier League’s spending restrictions and UEFA’s financial rules by a very substantial amount. The Premier League says the arrangements affected more than £900 million of revenue and costs. The Commission therefore rejected the idea that the disputed accounting arrangements were merely technical breaches, concluding that the club intended to circumvent the rules. 

The Commission also found that City submitted misstated accounts and failed to disclose the true position of its finances to auditors and football regulators. In addition, during the Premier League investigation, the club was found to have breached its obligations to co-operate and to act in the utmost good faith. Three of the four alleged failures to co-operate were upheld. The Premier League says the Commission found that City made concerted efforts to obstruct or frustrate the investigation. 

These findings are particularly significant because Manchester City has consistently denied wrongdoing. Following publication of the findings, the club said it was disappointed and surprised and maintained that it was innocent of the accusations. City has stated that it possesses a “comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence” supporting its position and intends to appeal, arguing that the Commission’s decision contains “material errors of law, principle and fact”. 

Importantly, the Commission has not yet imposed a punishment. The Premier League’s rules give the Commission wide discretion, including the ability to impose fines, points deductions and other sporting sanctions. Any sanction will therefore be a separate and potentially very consequential stage of the process. 

Manchester City also has a right of appeal to an independent Appeal Board. That Board can uphold the decision, overturn it or vary the Commission’s order. Consequently, the findings announced this week represent a major stage in the case, but they are not necessarily the final legal position. 

The Premier League has described the case and the decision as the most significant disciplinary matter in its history. Nevertheless, several issues remain unresolved, most importantly, the sanction and the outcome of any appeal. The full Commission decision has not yet been published and the continuing proceedings remain subject to confidentiality requirements. 

In essence, the Commission has accepted the Premier League’s case that Manchester City systematically breached its financial rules over a prolonged period and deliberately concealed the true financial arrangements behind some sponsorship and expenditure. The next major questions are therefore what punishment will be imposed, whether City will succeed in its appeal, and what consequences – if any – the findings will ultimately have for the club’s historical results, titles and European participation.

Let us look at those three issues with a view to getting the opinion of Holics examining the case:

What punishment should be meted out?

The independent Commission’s findings against Manchester City are potentially much more consequential than an ordinary financial-rule breach. The Commission found that City had used “sham” commercial arrangements, misstated accounts and significantly breached Premier League and UEFA spending limits over all nine seasons examined. It also found City guilty of three of four alleged failures to co-operate with the Premier League investigation. 

However, no punishment has yet been imposed. The sanction will be considered at a separate hearing before the independent Commission. City also has the right to appeal the findings, with the deadline currently 2 October. An appeal would be heard by a new three-person Appeal Board, rather than by the Court of Arbitration for Sport, to whom they have no right of appeal. 

The obvious potential sanction is a very substantial points deduction. There is no established tariff for conduct on this scale. Everton, for example, received a 10-point deduction for a much smaller PSR breach, subsequently reduced on appeal to six points. City’s case is fundamentally different in both the duration and the nature and scale of the alleged financial manipulation. Consequently, any points penalty cannot sensibly be calculated simply by applying the Everton precedent. 

A points deduction could potentially be applied to the current season, although the precise timing would depend upon the sanction and appeal process. A sufficiently large deduction could have consequences for City’s league position, including the possibility of relegation. That is a possible consequence, not a decision that has been announced. But many commentators feel even this may be inadequate punishment. 

Another possibility is a substantial financial penalty. The Commission has found that more than £900 million of revenue and costs were affected by the arrangements. The eventual sanction is likely to take into account not merely the financial scale but also the Commission’s findings concerning deliberate conduct and the club’s failure to co-operate. 

There is also the much more complicated question of past Premier League titles. If the Commission’s judgements ultimately survive appeal, the Premier League could potentially seek retrospective sporting consequences. Reports have raised the possibility of titles being removed or seasons being retrospectively altered, but, as yet, there has been no ruling that City’s titles will be stripped. Such a step would raise extraordinarily difficult questions about whether runners-up should become champions, how prize money should be treated and whether other clubs could bring financial claims

The new Independent Football Regulator (IFR) is an important additional factor, but its role needs to be understood carefully. The IFR has statutory powers concerning the suitability of owners and directors. It can assess whether an incumbent owner or director remains suitable where it has grounds for concern, and, in appropriate circumstances, can require an unsuitable owner or director to leave or disqualify them. 

Might City succeed in their appeal ? 

Despite the apparent bullishness of Ferran Soriano, C114y are in a very deep pit. Presumably, their ‘irrefutable evidence’ was used in the original hearing and signally failed to impress the commission. The word ‘sham’ is used no less than eight times in the report published yesterday  and specific reference is made in the judgment to the ‘Disguised Funding Scheme’ set up by the club to mask payments from ADUG . There is also the matter of the unreliability and dishonesty of some of the witnesses put forward by the club. They will not be recalled. Thus, for an appeal to succeed the club has to produce significant new evidence that fundamentally strengthens City’s case and overturns the judgments made by the original Commission. I am inclined to agree with Jamie Carragher (not words I often write!) that Soriano is indulging in gaslighting. 

The original Commission took considerable time to consider the evidence and have been painstaking in their evaluation so unless it can be proved that they have made significant errors, or C114y produce evidence they did not share with the original Commission it seems highly unlikely that the Commission’s judgment will be substantially reversed. This is the opinion of a couple of legal friends and tallies with the view of Stefan Borson who seems to be one of the leading authorities in football’s financial / legal space.

What are the likely consequences? 

This is the hardest area to predict with any certainty and any suggestions I make are pure speculation. 

Firstly this is likely to become a very strange season. The atmosphere when C114y are playing away will be very hostile. At the Etihad the wagons may indeed circle but there will also be C114y fans disgusted at the state of the club. It will be very hard for C114y players to sustain their form and motivation throughout a season when whatever the outcome of games, they may be relegated anyway. 

Any appeal may apparently take several months to be fully completed and the final judgment to be given. It is not yet clear whether sanctions will be announced before any appeal. The Premier League has said its intention is for the full process, including any appeals, to be concluded as soon as possible. Lisa Nandy, the Sports Minister echoed this when interviewed yesterday. 

So, I would expect the League to want the sanctions process to move forward rather than to wait for potentially many months for the appeal process to be completed. However, we don’t yet have a published timetable saying that the sanction will definitely be announced before the appeal is heard.

There is a precedent for sanctions and appeals being dealt with separately. In Everton’s case, for example, the club’s two-point deduction was imposed and then appealed, with the Appeal Board subsequently varying the punishment. 

My view as to an appropriate punishment if any appeal fails is that it should fall into several parts:

1. C114 y should be expelled from the Premier League. Their dishonesty and cynicism towards the competition merits very severe action.

If they are expelled they would have to apply to join the EFL at the bottom of the pyramid (Division 2) and if accepted, must work their way back up. 

2. A significant fine should be levied. A fine is the least important aspect because the owners of this club have almost inexhaustible cash reserves, but it should reflect income illegally gained leaving individual clubs to pursue claims for compensation although a class action could still follow. It might be a very substantial sum indeed.

3. The club should surrender all honours it has won during the period under review but the titles should not be reassigned. They should be categorised as ‘not awarded’ simply because it is too difficult to reassign them accurately. 

4. The Independent Regulator should order a change of ownership and the club should be sold. It may follow that the Regulator eventually bans Nation States from owning League football clubs but that is for another day. 

These four  steps would effectively destroy the club, stripping it back to the lowest league status, taking away titles won in the era under review (whether the Premier League extend its investigations from 2018 to 2026 is a moot point), effecting a change in ownership and reducing a once proud club to Ground Zero. It should however be a clean and honest club for the  first time in eighteen years. 

What thoughts do other Holics have? 

62 Drinks to “Football does the ‘Poznan’ back to City!”

  1. 1
    ClockEndRider says:

    Unfortunately the latest in a long line of weak as piss, poor excuses for Prime Ministers has already signalled the workings and impact of the AD diplomatic assault with a quite ridiculous comparison of the Everton situation and thus proven case, under an Independent Committee, with more than 99% of charges proven, against C114y. See link below.
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/crkgwvv8xvw0o.
    The quote “It is “frustrating when people rush to judgement” is entirely typical of this man and the entire political class of thusicountry. This is typical UK political gaslighting. What rush has there been? The emails were first made public, what, 7,8 years ago. The charges were first brought, what, 3 years ago. FFS if this is a rush then I don’t want to get in a queue behind Burnham.

  2. 2
    Countryman100 says:

    CER. No politics in the bar please.

  3. 3
    ClockEndRider says:

    This is not politics. Read what is written without overlaying your own political biases. As I have done.

  4. 4
    TTG says:

    Avoiding any political judgments or biases it is interesting that a former Mayor of Manchester should become Prime Minister given his relationship with ADUG who have indeed invested significantly in Manchester
    But he is an Evertonian too and must be concerned that any points deduction is proportionate with Everton’s punishment . Lisa Nandy has already suggested that the Government want to resolve this asap

  5. 5
    Countryman100 says:

    CER. You have described the current PM as piss poor. That is a political view. You have every righty’s hold it but it is against our rules to put it into the bar. Can I suggest that you redraft your post to say that you wish Burnham had not weighed into the City debate, a view which is not political and with which I completely agree and have already stated elsewhere.

  6. 6
    ClockEndRider says:

    After reflection, I accept that my post at 1 above was beyond the acceptable bounds and not in keeping with the finest traditions of Dave Faber and the blog. My anger at what has gone on with C114y, allied to my natural latin temperament got the better of me and I went beyond acceptable bounds. These are reasons, not excuses, because at my age I ought to be able to control my natural, erm, volatility much better. I unreservedly withdraw the first comment about Burnham and put myself at the mercy of the bar.

  7. 7
    TTG says:

    Well said CER

  8. 8
    Bathgooner says:

    A considered uncontentious opinion from a true football man:

    https://x.com/henrywinter/status/2105362935270756466?s=46

  9. 9
  10. 10
    ClockEndRider says:

    When I grow up, I want to be able to write reasoned pieces like that.
    We can all dream.

  11. 11
    ClockEndRider says:

    And yet all we hear is this nonsense about a “red cartel”. It is part of the City ownership- inspired war on truth, and is yet another of their stories with no anchor in reality. Lest we forget, how about their comments about “the tyranny of the majority”. Like democracy, you mean?
    How about the Blue Cartel of Chelsea and City who have both been proven guilty of skewing the playing field massively in their favour at the expense of every other club – blue, red, white, yellow?
    Tumbleweed.

  12. 12
    ClockEndRider says:

    And these clubs – City , Chelsea, others- constantly bang on about their heritage gojng back to 18 hundred and grandad. Yet the ignorant, the stupid and the bad actors either are incapable , unwilling or deliberately obfuscating when it comes to the fact that in all this time they have made little to no impact on the domestic and European football scenes, as United , Liverpool, and domestically, Arsenal have, in the same time period.
    Yeah thats right. It’s somebody else’s fault.
    Pitiful.

  13. 13
    TTG says:

    CER
    I think you’ve done just what you aspired to. That’s a reasoned yet impassioned piece. Thankyou
    This is an issue that has affected football fans in a way I’ve not seen before . I shall always remember those who act dishonestly in this scenario or who take sides like Guardiola using their influence to convince fans simply out of the past relationships they’ve had with the people who have jeopardised the integrity of English football. He knew nothing of the web of dishonesty taking shape around him . Of course he didn’t

  14. 14
    Countryman100 says:

    TTG @13

    Exactly. In the words of Claude Rains in Casablanca, playing Captain Louis Renault “I am shocked, shocked to find that gambling has been going on here!” (Flunkey “ your winnings Captain” “Oh thank you”).

  15. 15
    ClockEndRider says:

    C100- were I not such a Luddite, I would add the requisite Casablanca gif.
    Thank you.

  16. 16
    OsakaMatt says:

    Thanks TTG, an excellent summary.
    Thanks for the several links gents and very well said C100@5
    and CER @6, and also @11, gotta love this place.

    As for my own thoughts…

    I agree with your four points TTG. Though the period after 2018
    needs to be considered too. I do not believe the cheating
    stopped. It is all fruit of a poisoned tree and all the titles
    / trophies until now should be listed as “Not Awarded”. It is a very
    bad look for English football’s reputation in the future to have
    so many Not Awarded in the records forever but the bullet
    should be bitten in the interests of justice to the very, very many
    who were cheated.

    I share Nandy’s view that it t’were best done quickly. I do not
    share Burnham’s unfortunate comparison with the Everton
    situation. I also don’t share the Barcodes guy’s well-intentioned
    reasoning @9 for the points deduction either – there is no way C114y
    should be allowed to frame their punishment as some desperate
    and heroic battle against the odds etc etc – boot them now, and
    admission into league two should only come with new owners and
    an acceptance of guilt.

    I agree with Ned in the last drinks that it’s good C114y are
    going to Anfield. I feel sure that Liverpool are one of the clubs
    who have leaked that a simple relegation is not sufficient in the
    clubs view and equally sure that C114y will be left in no doubt
    of the contempt in which they are now held.

    Also. It wasn’t just the owners, many others participated in this sustained
    fraud and should, to use the old Jockey Club’s phrase, be warned off.
    No sneaking into jobs at other PL clubs after a couple of years laying
    low and trotting out some “I was only obeying orders” crap. They took
    the pieces of silver and knowingly cheated everyone. Get thee gone.

    Another elephant in the room for us would be Mikel’s next words on the
    matter. I think he will be asked – he was with C114y but he, along with us all of course, has been cheated royally. I hope he is clear but it is going to be difficult.

  17. 17
    North Bank Ned says:

    That is a heroic summary of 40 pages of legalese, TTG.

    The language of the Independent Judicial Commission’s summary report is strong and unequivocal that City is guilty as charged. However, as you rightly point out, we are far from the end of this matter.

    M’ learned friends tell me that the summary report appears to have been carefully worded to minimise the risk of City’s lawyers successfully challenging it on appeal on grounds of errors in process or law. The scope for introducing new evidence is also extremely narrow. The commission says the core bundle of key documents submitted to it ran to many tens of thousands of pages; the index alone ran to more than 750 pages. It is difficult to imagine that any evidence was left unturned, especially the ‘incontrovertible evidence’ City says proves its innocence.

    Given how tenaciously City’s senior figures are repeatedly doubling down on their assertions of innocence in the face of the evidence presented, it is also difficult to imagine this not ending up in the High Court.

    The next key point appears to be the sanctions hearing and whether it is held before or after the appeal against the verdict. We do not know that timetable. My own view is that sanctions should be announced no later than Matchweek 19 so the second half of the season, with every club still to play all the others at least once, can be played with some certainty.

    Regarding the pressure being applied to the UK government by Abu Dhabi, which is real and could have significant consequences for bilateral trade and investment, the optimal solution for the UK government, regardless of the individuals concerned, would be to resolve the matter as rapidly as possible, on the basis of least said, soonest mended. The initial crescendo of public outrage gives the government some political cover in the short term, while maintaining this as a private, if high-profile, legal dispute in which, in a country with the rule of law, it cannot intervene.

    The Blu Tack holding that fig leaf in place will weaken as the case drags on. No 10 will also not want the Independent Football Regulator putting its oar in before it absolutely has to. For the government, riding out Abu Dhabi retaliation for a severe sanction imposed by the PL would be one thing, albeit uncomfortable, but a UK regulatory agency forcing City officials to resign or the club to be sold would be something completely different.

  18. 18
    North Bank Ned says:

    OM@16: It would be amusing — well, I would be amused — if, as City ran out, the Anfield PA blared out the first verse of Cockney Rebel’s Make Me Smile

    You’ve done it all, you’ve broken every code
    And pulled the Rebel to the floor
    You spoilt the game, no matter what you say
    For only metal, what a bore
    Blue eyes, blue eyes, how come you tell so many lies?

    I am hoping this year’s BRIT Awards will have a special category for C114y songs. There should be a lot of good entries.

  19. 19
    North Bank Ned says:

    More Miguel, on toxicity

  20. 20
    Up4GrabsNow! says:

    Who’s humble now?

    Agree very much with TTG’s 1-4 punishment, but I’d tweak it slightly:
    1. Expel them from the PL – but not to EFL. They can eff off to the Saudi or UAE league; or wind the club down completely, Enron-style
    2. The fine needs to be billions and divvied up among every team they ever played from 2009 to present
    3. Yep, vacate everything they won. Just a ________* for that year.
    4. 100% agree, no more state ownership. They fail the “fit & proper” test

    Furthermore:
    – Widen the investigation to include 2018-2026
    – Full tax audit, last 20 years
    – Criminal proceedings against those individuals who were complicit, didn’t cooperate or perjured themselves
    – An accounting of the impact (inflation) their fraud had overall on player transfer fees, wages, ticket prices, teams missing out on Europe, demotion; not to mention players “stolen” from competitors like Arsenal, Everton and Aston Villa
    – Full disclosure of all double payments (Mancini, Yaya, Pep?)
    – Full disclosure on all transfers in – what did Dortmund really get for Haaland?
    – In 2027, a bronze statue of of Rui Pinto where the “Eti(we’ve been)had” used to stand before it was razed.

    The PL watchdogs were asleep. A junior trainee accountant could see that they were cooking the books from the get-go. Shame on the PL for not catching this 15 years ago. The integrity of the PL has been severely tainted.

    Funny one on Handbrake Off: “Guilty on 114 of the 115 charges. The only one they were cleared of was “overcrowding at the Etihad” 🙂

    “Sham-pagne Supernova” ya bushy browed freaks!

  21. 21
    OsakaMatt says:

    @18, 19 NBN
    That would be funny Ned, but I think they are going to get slaughtered
    by the crowd anyway. I’m looking forward to it, a well-deserved roasting.

    And thanks for the link too, I agree with Delaney
    that the defiance now is just delusional, though I think I would say the
    comparable industrial scale cheating would be Russia’s decades of doping
    in athletics. Other countries too of course. Russia have not been missed
    at the Olympics just as Man City won’t be missed and the idea of bringing
    down football is just absurd bluster.

  22. 22
    Bathgooner says:

    A comprehensive summary of the Commission’s report. Thank you TTG.

    I am in accordance with the crowd:

    1. Expulsion from the PL with instruction to apply for entry to the foot of the pyramid if the EFL clubs will have them 9they will, for the £££)
    2. Removal of all titles gained deceitfully during the period examined and all subsequent titles also gained as a result of the deceit.
    3. Referral of all club executives involved in the deception to the CPS and the club to HMRC
    4. Massive points deduction ensuring relegation in their eventual return to the PL (PL cannot impose points deductions in the EFL) extended over nine years to ensure recurrent difficulty in retaining PL status.
    5. Designation of UAE owners as unfit and improper persons to run a UK football club with instruction to sell up and GTF.
    6. Massive fine, at least £930m to be distributed in compensation pro rata to all clubs who played in the PL during the period of proven fraud.

    Unlike the Prime Minister, I think the removal of the owners is key to the survival of City as a football club at some level or other. No-one can believe this calculated fraud can have stopped after 2018 or that this cabal of cheats would not attempt a new scam if they continue to run the club. If you believe that, I have a bridge to sell you. Interestingly it has been revealed that Andy Pandy was heavily indebted to UAE money for several of the developments in Manchester that he claimed as achievements on his CV and there have been calls for further investigation of the relationships therein as there are already noises about inappropriately priced land deals. Oh, Andy, perhaps you should have kept your gob shut and you certainly should not, in your own words, “intervene further”. I wonder how far he has intervened in the process already. Interestingly, Mansour is calling in his debts in order to fight his corner, first Pep, then Andy and now Etihad (wholly owned by his family).

  23. 23
    Countryman100 says:

    Dan Neidle, a specialist in tax issues has just published the following. There is a lot of detail behind it, but I think the headline is sufficient for this forum

    Manchester City cheated Premier League rules, the Commission found. Did it also cheat HMRC?

    We’ve examined the decision and leaked Mancini documents. We think City likely failed to pay £12m in tax.

    There should be a criminal investigation.

  24. 24
    Countryman100 says:

    For anyone who does have the appetite or the knowledge, here is the full report

    https://x.com/danneidle/status/2105561142365941812?s=61&t=cVFjCyGkt4y-Ne45LtfqkQ

  25. 25
    Bathgooner says:

    Thanks for the link, C100. If HMRC and the CPS get involved then if there’s a massive fine (£930m) for redistribution to the injured parties pro rata , ignoring expulsion/relegation/stripping of titles etc then it’s quite likely the club will be bankrupted and the owner will walk away. The loss of face of playing in the 4th or lower tiers will be intolerable for the Arabs.

  26. 26
    Boff says:

    Thanks TTG, and all others for their comments.
    The sheer arrogance of the perpetrators should be punished further.
    Not sure the Premier League have the legal ability to have c114$ banned from EFL
    totally – but that would be appropriate.
    Force the club to pay off the contracts of all employees.
    Force the club to honour all player contracts; and pay the difference in any subsequent
    contract with their new club (surely transfer fees and wages will be lowered across the board)
    …and most important – cancel all their remaining games this season, and force the club to re-imburse all affected clubs their lost revenue for those games.
    No punishment is enough.

  27. 27
    OsakaMatt says:

    Thanks for the link @24 C100, I think there is very little doubt from
    the deductive process outlined that it is evasion and I quite agree there should
    be a criminal investigation into all involved. The figure mentioned, £24 million,
    may not be much compared to £930million but it is a hell of a lot of money
    to most of us and people have been jailed for far less.

  28. 28
    Bathgooner says:

    Adam Clery adds his very enjoyable tuppence worth (checked to ensure there’s no covert transfer of additional coins under the table:

  29. 29
    Boff says:

    …and of course the GHF Predictathon results should also be re-tabulated (is that a word?)

  30. 30
    North Bank Ned says:

    C100: Thanks for the link. I am not a lawyer, but there appears to be a prima facie case for Serious Fraud Office and HMRC investigations into potential accounting fraud and tax evasion. Neidle implies that HMRC’s investigations may already be underway.

    Boff@26: Relegation and promotion between the Premier League and the Championship is covered by the automatic three down/three up agreement between the Premier and Football leagues that dates to 1992. I assume that the mechanism for relegating City to the Championship would have to be a points deduction that left them in the bottom three at the end of the season. I don’t think it can just dump City into the Championship.

    However, if City is expelled from the PL, it would be without a league. To re-enter the league system, it would presumably have to apply to join the EFL. EFL rules state that new members can be admitted only to its lowest tier, i.e., League Two. New members must also meet the EFL’s requirements for ‘fit and proper’ owners.

    The EFL has a cap of 72 teams across its three divisions and a two-up/two-down promotion/relegation system with the National League. It would have to ‘lose’ a third club to make room for City. Assuming no vacancy arises from a non-relegated League Two team going bust or being expelled, that would most likely be achieved by four teams being promoted to the Premier League (the usual three plus a fourth to replace expelled City), triggering a chain reaction down to League Two.

    The intriguing wrinkle is that the deadline for EFL membership applications is November 1 for the following season.

  31. 31
    Potsticker says:

    Boff@29: the Predictathon prize winnings were spent … wild night in Vegas

  32. 32
    TTG says:

    Boff,
    As I understand it , if C114y are expelled from the Premier League , they will have to apply to join the EFL. I’m not sure if the EFL woukd think it a wizard wheeze to have them playing down there or the universal opprobrium ( I love that word!) will be such that they will not be elected to the league . Someone will presumably take them even it is the Northern Fishmongers Combination but it will be hard to recruit top players to join a project that may be several seasons away from the Premier League and even further from European football .
    What may happen is that rather like AFC Wimbledon and Milton Keynes Dons, true supporters may start up the club again and it may climb the pyramid . But this ghastly ADUG project will wither on the vine , victims of their own greed .

  33. 33
    North Bank Ned says:

    Boff@29: The Predictathon’s outcome is determined by the final official Premier League table. TTG and I remind all players of the special guidance we provided before the season:

    This season’s game carries added jeopardy for players because of the 115 charges against Manchester City, which could lead to a points deduction. Players are advised to take this into account when making their predictions. As a reminder, changes to predictions will be accepted up to the [entry] deadline, but not after it.

  34. 34
    TTG says:

    Ned
    You’ve clarified this much better than me but we’ve drawn the same conclusion. C114y’s behaviour and the extent that is revealed of their perfidy may determine if they will be taken back. They’ve not made a good start !

  35. 35
    Countryman100 says:

    Away from C114y some interesting updates from our club.

    https://x.com/timpayton/status/2105690127116775668?s=61&t=cVFjCyGkt4y-Ne45LtfqkQ

  36. 36
    CkockEndRider says:

    If the three heavy hitters seconded to the board from the Kroenke mothership can’t find a way to make it work, then it’s probably not realistically doable, I humbly suggest.
    As one commenter says, the wifi could do with an upgrade as well as the bar and food facilities!

  37. 37
    ClockEndRider says:

    Freudian slip at 36 above, before anyone says it.

  38. 38
    Countryman100 says:

    Just realised I posted a link to X which not all can access. Here’s the same info in a link to Pravda.

    https://www.arsenal.com/news/supporters-join-josh-kroenke-and-richard-garlick-at-aab-apUMv0T6WR8R

  39. 39
    ClockEndRider says:

    As someone who tries to go to away games whenever possible (Munich next month..), although not with the same frequency and commitment as C100, I found the quote below, taken from the website article linked in 38 above, very interesting:
    “ Addressing an AST submission to the meeting about away ticketing, we provided an update on away ticket transparency and the season-ticket waiting list.
    We confirmed that away-credit information will initially be published twice each season, as part of our mid-season and post-season ticketing reviews. This will include information on the number of members at defined credit thresholds and the proportion of tickets purchased by eligible credit-holding members. Supporter representatives welcomed the commitment to increased transparency. “
    Any thoughts, C100?

  40. 40
    North Bank Ned says:

    My question would be this, if City’s defence at the appeal hearing is going to be that the ‘sham’ sponsorships were actually funded by the Abu Dhabi government and states are allowed to fund clubs under Premier League rules, so the monwy was clean, why didn’t the Abu Dhabi government just give City the money directly rather than go through the rigmarole of routing it through Abu Dhabi companies.

  41. 41
    TTG says:

    Ned@40
    That is the obvious question but it’s worth noting that Sheikh Mansour was totally unaware ( apparently) of these arrangements. I’d it feasible to believe he was unaware of a billion pound investment in the club from the Abu Dhabi government?

  42. 42
    ClockEndRider says:

    Ned@40- spot on. I really don’t understand what kind of a defence that is other than a not very veiled threat not to eff with the AD state. Is it not effectively confirming that the apparent contracts were a sham? Which in turn means that they were breaking PL rules by not treating in utmost good faith? At every turn they just mire themselves ever more deeply.
    And we are still to see the incontrovertible evidence they have spoken about so far.

  43. 43
    Countryman100 says:

    CER @39. I admire the commitment to transparency but am puzzled by why they will only present these data twice a season. The only reason I remain on X (which is a cess pit) is because of the quite outstanding information provided by @bootifulgame and @arsenalfixturenews which is invaluable to the away going Gooner. @bootifulgame provides those data about how many members are at which credit level (and loads more, including minute by minute updates on how many tix remain for any given game) in his incredible spreadsheet which is updated in real time. I have always believed he has access to Arsenal data. If he has it, why don’t the club?

  44. 44
  45. 45
    OsakaMatt says:

    That is not good news, though i heard, fingers crossed, that
    Kai’s injury is not so bad.

  46. 46
    OsakaMatt says:

    Ode seems ok after being booted by Bernardo Silva
    and Saliba is targeting a November return.

  47. 47
    Trev says:

    Many thanks TTG for another helpful, clear and time consuming piece.

  48. 48
    Noosa Gooner says:

    Thanks TTG
    Probably a bit early to speculate on what may eventuate for Citeh’s players / contracts etc. but it would be good if we could steal Semenyo from them at a bargain basement price. Haaland to Real Madrid and I don’t think that leaves anyone we may want.
    UTA.

  49. 49
    TTG says:

    If Erling was willing to be humble I’m sure we could find a place for him
    The deal they did with Dortmund is one of the dodgiest you could imagine

  50. 50
    North Bank Ned says:

    Steals in amid the chaos to slot home.

  51. 51
    OsakaMatt says:

    Well in Ned, fine quick single 👋👋

    Jury’s out on Semenyo for me, he disappeared last 5 PL games. We could take the young
    Moroccan lad though not sure where he would play to be honest.

    Halaand would have to be very humble indeed and sign a pledge not to be a
    greedy, gullible, gannet. Also he would have to release a cover of North London
    Forever in Norway. But before all of that he has to kick Bernardo Silva hard.

  52. 52
    North Bank Ned says:

    NG@48: Semenyo would be a great pick-up, although it would probably be as a replacement for Eze. I’d look at Doku, too; Arteta could turn him into a real player on a wing where we need reinforcement. Rico Lewis would be worth running the rule over if Arteta thinks he needs more cover at right back for the long term, and Rayan Cherki, too, given he is only 23. Guéhi and Gvardiol are of the requisite quality, but we have better at centre-back. O’Reilly, too, would also be surplus to requirements. I wouldn’t touch Foden or Enzo Fernández with a bargepole, and Haaland will be off to Spain.

  53. 53
    North Bank Ned says:

    The Swiss Ramble has dived into the C114y financials in his substack today.
    https://swissramble.substack.com/p/financial-implications-of-the-manchester

    On the basis of a picture is worth a thousand words, this is his portrait of the scale of the sham commercial contracts, which he describes as really being a disguised equity contribution. It is the dark blue part of each bar that is so much larger than the legitimate revenues.

    Swiss Ramble also calculates that Abu Dhabi’s true equity injection into the club over the nine seasons the PL investigated was £2.1 billion, more than all the other clubs in the PL put together. He also reminds us of an AW quote from back in the day, “It’s financial doping, and it will one day catch up with them.”

  54. 54
    TTG says:

    A few noble Holics met for lunch today close to the Home of Football.
    There was much speculation about the announcement Rui Pinto, the whistleblower who exposed the leaks subsequently published in Der Spiegel , threatens to make at 7pm UK time tonight which he suggests might be a blockbuster ! We await it with interest
    If it is more C114y material they may become at least C200 y !

  55. 55
    North Bank Ned says:

    TTG@54: Laddies who do lunch. What could possibly go wrong?

    Considering the direction of travel of the disguised payments illustrated by Swiss Ramble’s chart above, is there any reason to think that the accounting shenanigans suddenly ceased in the 2018-19 season? Just askin’.

  56. 56
    North Bank Ned says:

    Just as shocking is what Swiss Ramble calculates City’s real losses to have been over the nine seasons.

  57. 57
    ClockEndRider says:

    Ned@56- who’d a f*ckin’ liberty, in the words of Catherine Tate’s “ Nan”. Although entirely unsurprising.
    A fine lunch at an Italian restaurant in N1 with a number of the guilty of this bar.
    TTG@ 54- not so much noble as nobly, given the state if some of our our knees, hips etc. A fine lunch, by any estimation.
    Ned again- The numbers above are just gobsmacking. I am baffled by the wild fluctuations in defence these people seek to hide their wrong doing behind. There is a body if incontrovertible evidence. But we can’t present it. The sponsorships are all accurate. Yet financial records show otherwise.
    In the words of some Brummie bloke who wrote stuff a long time ago:
    Doctor: What is it she does now? Look, how she rubs her hands
    Gentlewoman: It is an accustomed action with her, to seem thus
    washing her hands: I have known her continue in
    this a quarter of an hour.
    LADY MACBETH: Yet here’s a spot.
    Doctor: Hark! she speaks: I will set down what comes from
    her, to satisfy my remembrance the more strongly.
    LADY MACBETH: Out, damned spot! out, I say!–One: two: why,
    then, ’tis time to do’t.–Hell is murky!–Fie, my
    lord, fie! a soldier, and afeard? What need we
    fear who knows it, when none can call our power to
    account?–

    I’ve had enough of these people.

  58. 58
    ClockEndRider says:

    Nobbly, not nobly

  59. 59
    ClockEndRider says:

    Even better, having looked it up, years after O level Eng Lit, the speech continues:
    LADY MACBETH Here’s the smell of the blood still: all the
    perfumes of Arabia will not sweeten this little
    hand. Oh, oh, oh!

  60. 60
    Countryman100 says:

    So I wake-up from my post lunch nap (Bath was forcing that red wine down me) to find that big Vik has scored again for Sweden! Three games in a row!

  61. 61
  62. 62
    Bathgooner says:

    >>>>>>>>>>>>>>