
We are interrupting our discussion on the Great Divide to examine the breaking news brought to us this afternoon. News that may have implications which have lasting impacts on English football.
I begin by quoting from Ornstein in this afternoon’s Athletic:
“Manchester City have been found guilty on almost all of the charges relating to breaches of the Premier League’s financial regulations.
“The sanctions have not been decided, with all possibilities remaining on the table, and City are expected to appeal.
”City have been found guilty on all but one of the 115 charges, according to sources briefed on the matter who spoke anonymously as they were not authorised to do so publicly. They were first charged in February 2023 following a four-year investigation.
“A City spokesperson told The Athletic: “The Premier League process remains ongoing, with significant elements to be completed, and subject to strict confidentiality. As such Manchester City FC’s position remains consistent with the club’s statement of February 2023.
“The club has diligently respected due process for eight years on the basis the Premier League board and executive would behave as an independent, impartial and fair minded regulator, free from partisan influence.”
This is an issue which we have fervently debated on here for three years . When they were first charged, had an immediate early verdict followed we would probably have won two further titles. Last season, we beat them without any points deductions, with Pep Guardiola in charge, and in the face of the arrogance that seeps out of every pore of a club that is about to be disembowelled after persistent infringements over eleven years – and nobody has formally investigated their potential guilt over the years beyond those covered by their charges.
This is probably the biggest scandal in English football history and the litigious nature of C114y (we’ve amended their moniker to reflect the number of charges apparently proved by the tribunal) has meant that blogs and media outlets have been very reluctant to speculate about their guilt and what would happen if their guilt was proven. I first read of their alleged wrongdoing in emails published by Der Spiegel around eight years ago. The culture engendered in those emails was repulsive, cynical and deeply arrogant. But was it a genuine reflection? It would now appear that it was.
Some people I’ve spoken to are still uncertain about whether this is reliable. It is from Ornstein who works for an organ of the New York Times. Can you imagine them not checking its veracity before publishing? In C114y’s response you can sense the shock and defensiveness about where they go from here. Division 2 might be an appropriate destination.
There are also those of a pessimistic nature who still expect C114y to get away with it – “like Chelsea it will be a slap on the wrist”.
May I quote from the excellent Magic Hat on Twitter to answer this:
“For those thinking Man City will get a lenient punishment like Chelsea did, that simply won’t be the case.
“The PL convinced an IC Panel that Chelsea (a) did not gain any Sporting Advantage, (b) they were no longer owned/run by the perpetrators, and (c) they were very compliant (even self-reporting).
“Man City’s case is the opposite of those 3 factors:
1) They gained a monstrous sporting advantage. Hundreds upon hundreds of millions over PSR limits.
2) They are still owned / run by the people that did it.
3) They have gone to extreme lengths to avoid justice. They hid it all (only an email hack caught them – the rules could not).
“They refused to comply with the investigation.
“They committed perjury at CAS.
“Henry Winter also agrees.
“Fining a club as wealthy as Manchester City would be pointless. If their appeal fails, it has to be a points deduction leading to relegation.”
If I might say so, I have always understood the reluctance to believe that C114y would be found guilty and severely sanctioned. It was almost too good to be true that the only serious rival to us in the Premier League might suffer a huge points deduction. But the Premier League passed the point of no return when they committed to charging a club as rich and litigious as City. If those charges had failed, it might have led to the resignation of the whole management structure at the Premier League and left C114y untouchable because of their money and power. I’ve always believed that ultimately C114y would be blown to bits .
What that might mean may take a while to decide. C114y might try to drag things out, appeal and try every legal trick they can to delay things. But now they face the court of universal opprobrium, of national indignation and fury and disgust. What if their team bolstered by £400 million of players whom they might not have legitimately acquired does win the League? Who will accept it as a fair and valid result? Law suits will pile up and if they hope to deflect and overturn 114 charges (and rumours suggest there may be more in the pipeline ) surely they will eventually have to suck up their punishment or become the pariahs of English and European football. But of course they are that already!
C114y – it’s taken a long time but the game is up. Football knows what you did and who you actually are. You will find that sympathy is in very short supply.









Superb and important piece TTG. May I begin the opprobium?
Thanks TTG – all involved with this.
I was about to post a drink – too late – in the last bar which I fortunately managed to salvage – and so –
I have refused to believe throughout this horrendously extended process that C115y could be allowed to “get away with it”.
Some of the charges of which they are guilty relate to PSR rules. Many are more serious like failing to provide the requested / demanded financial information on salaries, transfers etc; falsifying salary information; disguising payments direct to the club from sheikh Mansour as sponsorships …… which amount to fraud.
There is absolutely no point fining these cheats any amount of money.
Chelsea got away with a fine for their indiscretions because they self reported. City, by any stretch of the imagination, have not. This has to result in footballing sanctions.
Relegate them to League 2. Ban transfers for as many years as they have cheated. As a minimum, remove their name from all trophies won.
It then has to be decided whether you promote second placed teams to champions / runners up to winners. And what about clubs who have missed out on Champions League income. Or clubs who have been relegated – managers who have lost their jobs as a result.
The extent of their cheating is huge. The punishment needs to match
Read it now, TTG – brilliant !
Apparently C114y have been given 14 days to appeal so that might curtail the shenanigans.
And they cannot go to CAS.
What do we want?
Justice.
When do we want it?
Now.
Now off to read TTG’s emergency piece.
Thanks C100 and Trev
If C114y’s appeal fails the punishment could and should be massive and they will be heavily sued by lots of clubs . The biggest consequence is that it will throw the Predictathon into chaos . But beyond that many clubs have a legitimate axe to grind . For example we missed out on Champions League in 17/18 . If C114y are sanctioned for that season when they effectively took our place from 16/17 we could claim a minimum of £30 m . There will be loads of similar claims some much bigger .
Above all we might assemble at the Emirates tonight to celebrate our triumph in the League Cup in 2018 after a glorious 3-0 defeat to C114y. Mustafi will get the medal he so richly deserves
TTG- many thanks for penning this piece do quickly and hitting exactly the right tone. We all thought the moral high ground was ours (that is to say, that they had cheated) and it seems proven in effectively a court of law. What we now await is whether it turns out to be a court if justice. Justice would surely best be served by relegating these financial cheats.
You have been a consistent believer that they would be found guilty. I have always thought that political power would see them suffer very little actual penalty. The sheer weight of the apparent findings in terms of those upheld and those stricken off makes a meaningless punishment now unthinkable. You and I – and many others on this channel – had the great good fortune to work in the City of London, which rightly had the highest reputation for financial rectitude and probity for a very long time.We have always had the highest regard for fair play and sporting integrity in the UK. I hope this signals our country being the paragon of legal rectitude, at least as far as sport is concerned.
One further thing that I omitted from the hastily written article was the reaction of the Abu Dhabi ownership. This crisis is not where a carefully targeted ‘ sportswashing ‘ project was supposed to land. Huge costs, massive disdain and contempt from the sporting world and a place maybe in Division 2 . Disaffected stars not willing to climb back up the pyramid, plastic fans not willing to watch a side at that level and suffer the derision of other fans . Not a great look for a ‘ let’s boost the image of Abu Dhabi’ project
Tremendous piece TTG at perfect pitch. Plaudits for pace too.
Lots of great Drinks above. Quite like old times!
I hope the lawsuits pour in behind this verdict.
The compensation that City may have to pay to other clubs would get them liquidated. Then Sevco 2 would have to restart at the bottom of the pyramid. I don’t see Abu Dhabi sticking around for that.
One group of people at Middle Eastlands who might be glad if they find themselves in League 2 would be the academy players. They can expect lots of first team action cos there won’t be anyone else left ! 😆
“The club has diligently respected due process for eight years on the basis the Premier League board and executive would behave as an independent, impartial and fair minded regulator, free from partisan influence.”
That’ll be “diligently respected due process “ by failing to provide the information they were asked for. There are some straws being desperately clutched at tonight.
This is a very big deal. We’d be interested in a range of views on this .
Please don’t be shy. Even if you don’t usually post this is one of the most significant moments in English football history
Cheers TTG for a a brilliant summation of the biggest story to hit the EPL since its formation. Their guilt appeared obvious with the extensive delay in an announcement- if they had been found not guilty then this would have been advised very soon after the panel had come to that conclusion. Even now they do not have the integrity to accept their mis-deeds and negotiate the least damaging punishment.
The EPL will also want to minimise the reputational damage this has done to their product as well as all the clubs affected by C114’s cheating looking at financial re-imbursement.
Hopefully the process will not take as long to reach a final conclusion.
First, TTG, kudos to you for writing so rapidly and strongly on this. It is a seismic event for English football and the Premier League.
I have no idea what sanctions will ultimately be imposed on City once the appeal against the initial verdict has been heard, and, no doubt, an appeal against the sanctions will then be lodged. I also expect even more political pressure to come from the Gulf. Nor do I expect the sanctions to be settled expeditiously.
However, the scale of the charges and City’s approach to defending itself against them demand that the punishment be severe. In other leagues, clubs have been relegated for less. In addition, transfer bans would seem to fit the crime. Fines would have to be astronomical to have any meaningful impact on owners as wealthy as City Group. Expulsion from the PL/Football League would be the ultimate sanction.
I also think that getting the punishment right will be a critical test of the Premier League’s ability to maintain confidence in the sporting integrity of its competition.
As a first step, the verdicts on the charges need to be made public. We will then get a sense of whether the panel’s decision can withstand an appeal backed by the sort of legal fees that City can afford to throw at it, and on what grounds any challenge might be brought.
There is clearly a lot of antagonism towards City and the League that has built up among its clubs. After three years of watertight silence on the case, I can’t believe other than the verdicts were intentionally leaked by clubs who feel they were disadvantaged by City’s cheating and that resolving the issue was being dragged out for far too long.
Lawsuits will be inevitable from clubs that lost cups and titles to City in the years in question — Man U, Liverpool, Sunderland, Stoke and ourselves — as well as from clubs denied qualification for European tournaments by a place.
There is also the question of whether the verdict will give the government an excuse to step in with greater regulation of the professional game, especially under a government led by a football-playing prime minister.
The only certainty is that we are not at the end of this story, but at the beginning of the next chapter.
Ornstein in his own words:
https://www.youtube.com/live/TOgBSGd_XT8?si=WLLwDRPHBcvoYXFU
And Miguel Delaney:
Thanks TTG, great piece and many great drinks below.
Personally I think they should just be booted out now. Fines and
relegation to League 2 are not really significant enough as they
will be back again in a few seasons. I don’t believe that will
happen though.
Significant bans from football should be given to the guilty
individuals too. Many people were involved and knowingly
cheated.
I wonder if UEFA will get involved again apart from the
lawsuits from the clubs.
Quite apart from official sanction, which should be of the severest kind given the enormity, and number, of the offences, c114y will have to face constant jeering from the stands. Fans will let their views be known. As for the present squad, how could anybody continue to play for massive cheats without subjecting himself to well-deserved hatred, ridicule and contempt?
Rodri showing an incredible lack of awareness this morning –
“Our success wasn’t paid for with money – it was paid for with effort and teamwork – they cannot take our success away…”
Oh can’t they ? Keep watching buddy ….
A rather confused piece by Martin Samuel. To paraphrase, Yes they cheated, yes they must be severely punished, but I wish it were not the case. Samuel sounds like the fan who cried out when shoeless Joe Jackson was found guilty of cheating in the 1919 baseball World Series “ say it ain’t so, Sam!”
Man City verdict: A great victory — but ‘best league in world’ reduced to rubble
https://www.thetimes.com/article/00a2e6d3-a2a8-4e80-a422-f4d28f0e4e76?shareToken=6153eb1dabb29808419ddbaf5cbc925d
For those saying that the appeal will take years, The Guardian says not.
“According to the Premier League rulebook, the appeal process has a stricter time frame, whereby any party who wishes to appeal a decision by a judicial panel must do so by email within 14 days of a decision being announced. Under rule W.86 any hearing should conclude no longer than 12 weeks after the first appeal is submitted. Any decision by the appeal board must also be published, alongside full written reasons, within 30 days of the conclusion of the hearing.”
Of course we await the official announcement which will be the starting point for this timetable.
Some great points from Arseblog this morning.
C100 @19, that fat apologist for C115y is choking on having to change his tune.
I am astonished at the sudden outpouring of outrage from quarters who should have seen through the lies and obfuscations by the C115y hierarchy and their shills years ago. It was obvious very early on in the reign of Sheikh Mansour that something dodgy was going on at C115y to fund their sudden growth from a struggling outfit to a behemoth.
I look forward to more of their apologists in the broadcast and print media having to eat humble pie.
I will read TTG’s piece a little later, but indeed bath @ 22.
I imagine that the referees who got wined and dined in The Emirates (not the Stadium ;-)) will also appear dumbfounded. It all seemed so innocent and nice and kind, eh?
C***s.
League titles
20 Man Utd, Liverpool
14 Arsenal
10******** Man City
9 Everton
7 Aston Villa
6 Sunderland, Chelsea
4 Sheffield Wednesday, Newcastle
3 Blackburn, Huddersfield, Wolves, Leeds
2 Preston, Burnley, Portsmouth, Derby, Spurs
Kwasi Karteng, he the Chancellor that nearly wrecked the British economy was on Sky main news yesterday and was talking about Abu Dhabi and how this sporting project was meant to play out .
This development was obviously never on the agenda and he speculated how they would react to a worldwide humiliation that will resonate for years to come. It has been suggested they have applied diplomatic pressure already and are likely to double down on this approach when the actual sanction is known. Pity for them they will have a Government whose leader follows a team given a 10point penalty for one breach ( later reduced on appeal)
I’ve speculated on here that what they will do is to take their ball and try to revive the European Super League project . They may yet get a chance having been blown to bits to do the same to English football.
Thanks TTG
I think that relegation to League 2 would be the most appropriate sanction.
If financial fair play rules were also monitored over time, would any decent player be prepared to wade through the treacle of the lower leagues for at least four or five years to help them make their way back?
I think not.
UTA
Maybe Teflon Pep could come back as manager. Funny how he got out before the shit really hit the fan – prior knowledge surely not?
UTA
Red scousers all over this. Suggesting to sing this and others when they next play City
To the tune of Dancing Queen
Man City
Found guilty
Of the 114
Man City
Soon to be
Playing Forest Green
Oh yeah!
Seems timely
TTG@25- I don’t understand how City could look to blow up English football. They are the outlier. In order to create a new league or destroy the existing one, they would need others to come along with them, surely? And why would any other club do that? Could you expand?
Couldn’t happen to a more unpleasant set of fans. Worst in the PL.
And don’t try to pretend Guardiola quit before this season for any other reason than he knew what was coming.
And what about the fans who have spent fortunes on tickets and travel for over a decade chasing an impossible dream while these cheats mopped up 20 trophies with players they should never have had.
From their website, a list of their “partners”. These companies ought to be bloody well ashamed of themselves.
https://www.mancity.com/club/partners
CER @34, more like ‘accessories after the fact’!
I’m having fun picturing Erling Haaland being sold at police auction like a drug lord’s speedboat.
CER
Re your question my thinking was based on the dispute about Associated Party rules and the support that they got from the likes of Forest , Villa and Newcastle . Ironically these are three sides who have sold players to comply with the rules that C114y have do flagrantly broken .
All of those clubs dislike the system that operates within the PL . My scenario and it is a little far fetched would be that C114y revive the Super League project with the likes of Barca, Real Madrid and Juventus but ask those clubs miffed by the operation of the Associated Party rules to join them
Saudi Arabia has cooled on sport but might decide it was up for a European Super League where it could spend its dosh and not sell players . Villa might feel the same and Forest have a maverick owner .
My sense is that one option open to Abu Dhabi is to try to destroy the Premier League rather than sink out of trace down the pyramid . Sponsors might prefer the Big 4 English clubs but if the potential next tier could be guaranteed serious money they could become serious players pretty soon
It might be far fetched and malicious but I think that’s what we are confronting
CER at 34
As I occasionally found in the distant past Durex did not provide ideal protection . They certainly haven’t here
The PL’s Rule W.86 in full:
Where the Appeal Board Standard Directions apply, an Appeal Board will:
W.86.1. schedule the appeal hearing, which shall:
W.86.1.1. conclude no later than 12 weeks (84 days) after the filing of the
appeal pursuant to Rule W.81;
W.86.1.2. not exceed five days in duration and be heard in one block (i.e.
it will not go part-heard); and
W.86.1.3. address all matters which are required to dispose of the appeal;
W.86.2. set the dates for all remaining procedural steps leading up to and after
the appeal hearing including the date on which the Appeal Board must
provide its decision, together with written reasons, which shall be within 30
days after the final day of the appeal hearing; and
W.86.3. consider and decide any other procedural application, to include in
relation to the disapplication or variation of the Appeal Board Standard
Directions.
As a footnote, Man City can appeal the verdict and the resultant sanctions separately.
M’learned friends advise me that if the sanctions imposed on City are severe enough, its players are likely to have a good legal case to terminate their contracts unilaterally. So trips to Forest Green and Grimsby for Haaland and co. are unlikely.
CER@34: I doubt the extent of the reputational risk to City’s ‘partners’ will become clear until the final sanctions are known, and even then perhaps not for some time. We may never know which have contractual terms that protect them financially against a guilty verdict.
My 2 cents would be that most of the well-known global names will be able to brush it off. Their brands do not depend on association with City. As for its other partners, they may be too obscure to be tarnished. Hands up, anyone who knows without googling the answer who City’s ‘global partner’ e& is and what it does?
TTG@38- good point! No pun intended.
Ned@41 – my thinking was that the “ partners” might well look to cut links with City and cut off their revenue streams. I rather suspect that a few weeks of televised games where 50,000 people are singing the “you know what you are” song at City- even with Sky doing their fogging of the sound and using directional mikes – and they might not wish to have any association with a pariah like City. All publicity is not good publicity. Of course it’s all hugely hypocritical, but what goes around comes around.
CER&TTG@various: The PL is a golden goose that its owners will not recklessly kill. Most PL clubs would not be included in a Super League, and their owners would not willingly accept being the equivalent of Championship teams in a pan-European competition. One glance at the comparative financials of the English first and second tiers explains why.
An alternative to the Super League redux scenario and to the inter-club dynamics that TTG raises @37 is for the PL to reorganise itself so that private capital strengthens its position vis-à-vis state capital. This would manifest as PL club owners running the league in a way that more closely resembles how professional sports leagues in the US increase overall revenue while ensuring all owners’ snouts can get space at the trough. That would be a step towards the further Americanisation of the professional English game, but that is already the direction of travel.
Not to get too far ahead of ourselves, Abu Dhabi’s response to the eventual outcome will also be critical. How will it assess the damage to its global sportswashing project, and what will it do to contain it? Will the Saudi strategy towards the Khoshoggi killing be its blueprint: denial, then acknowledging a rogue operation, followed by ignoring all further criticism?
Nor should we forget the intra-Gulf dynamics. Abu Dhabi is not the only sportswasher in the region.
One possible outcome we have not yet discussed is that the UK government forces a sale of Man City, as happened at the Bus Stop, albeit in very different circumstances. I do think this is highly unlikely, given the damage it would do to the bilateral relationship between the UK and the UAE. From what little we know, the UAE has been pressuring the UK government to urge the PL to consider the potential economic damage to UK interests in the Gulf. But never say never.
Ned @41 my hnd goes firmly and quickly up.
As well as a great many people I’d say, though maybe not in Europe unless you are in my line of business (we actually work with/for them a lot): it is the new logo/front name for the company now called Emirates Telecommunications Group, formerly just known as Etisalat. My first ever business trip outside of Europe was in fact to their premises in Dubai.
So a big telecomms operator essentially, now with subsidiaries in quite a few Arab and African countries mainly.
So in some place they will be as well known as BT or Orange are over here, say. And more than Sobha sodding Realty, I suspect.
When it comes to global partners, it is well to remember the PL is even more of an export product than an English one.
CER@42: You make a good point. I don’t know the contractual mechanics for cutting sponsorship payments in these circumstances, or how much sponsors have paid up front, but City’s most recently reported financials show £340 million in commercial revenue, just over half of total operating revenue. Losing a chunk of it would hurt. UAE-based revenue is likely secure, but many other brands must be closely — and uneasily — monitoring the backlash.
Ollie@44: I always knew you were one in a million…
My 2 cents – no matter what happens the stench of 114 guilty verdicts is going to follow Shitty no matter where they go, including a Super League. Not being a narcissistic, billionaire sociopath like Mansour, I would dump Shitty and continue to play with all of my other toys in the basket. All while blaming the accountants, directors, attorneys, and Pep.
I’m thinking relegation to League 2 and a 10-year transfer ban is appropriate punishment.
From Miguel Delaney of the Indy
Exclusive: successful legal actions over City case could be worth over £200m to clubs who make claims – only four preserved “right to sue” under Section W
Was initially Arsenal, who are understood to have been followed by Spurs, Man United and Liverpool
City’s stance is still that from February 2023, that they insist on their innocence.
*kicks ball forward*
Slams it in!
Takes EPO, and thunders a left foot shot in from fully 114 yards, at no point admitting wrongdoing.
C100- swine.
Nice assist Ollie.
Well in for the half-ton, C100, a strike as honest as the day is long outside M11 3FF, which should surely now be reamed M11 4FFS.
Genius, Ned!
Emphatic finish, C100.
I wonder if CER thought EPO could make you travel back in time, or was just emulating C114y to get the goal after VAR review.
C114y Chairman Khaldoon
Al Mubarak has stated Cuty’d total belief in their innocence and that C114y have ‘ irrefutable’ proof of their innocence. Obviously they forgot to share this with the commission who sat in judgment before
Interesting that in the first minute at Wembley tonight Guehi has made a terrible error to let in Yamal . Could the news add to the pressure on C114y players on the pitch this season? We can only hope so
TTG@57- to paraphrase Claude Rains in Casablanca, I am shocked, shocked to find that a man who has commissioned cheating on an industrial scale has refused to acknowledge that he has commissioned cheating on an industrial scale.
TTG@57 & CER@58: The time-honoured playbook: deny, delay and dissemble. Nothing to see here, so move along, and anyone who doesn’t is biased and with agenda.
As Roy Keane said, noticeable that the Man City players were well off it tonight.
Thought Anthony Gordon was excellent. Game turned on the Kane penalty miss.
Semenyo, Guehi, Anderson, must all be thrilled at the possibilities before their new club.
They were quick enough to sign up for a club they clearly knew were awaiting the verdict on their many years of cheating. Enjoy your hyper-inflated salaries while they last, lads.
Trev@61- it would take a heart of stone not to laugh.
@56 Ollie
After a short 7 hour review – to allow for a competitive bidding process –
the well-taken 50 @50 by C100 stands.
I knew well under half of C114y’s global partners
to be honest though I was disappointed to see
Asahi Super Dry sullying the taste of their perfectly
reasonable beverage with such an unalluring partner.
I would boycott their product if the gout hadn’t made
that decision for me already 🍻
OM@64 – Age shall not weary, nor the years condemn…
Oh balls, they will actually
*finally celebrates with C100 after VAR @ 63*
Why is there nobody left in the stands????
Whilst I am as keen as the next morally outraged member of the football-following community that the cheats at the club occupying the ground formerly known as the Eastlands should suffer the maximum sanction possible for over a decade of lies, deception and fraud (viz: annulment of all titles won since 2009; immediate expulsion of the club from the PL with an instruction to apply to join the EFL next season but no guarantee of entry; a 115 points deduction extended over 10 seasons; a transfer ban for several seasons; removal of Mansour’s designation as a ‘fit and proper owner’ with an instruction to sell the club; support of litigation for financial losses by multiple other clubs), I suspect that wheeling and dealing at multiple levels (including governmental) that will accompany the official appeals process may mitigate the final sanctions significantly. None of us can be certain of the final sanctions. The finding of guilt over 114 of the 115 charges is only one step in the process and while some are confidently predicting that the guillotine is about to fall, I think we should temper our zeal for retribution lest we be deeply disappointed. Vermin have a propensity for evading traps.
So haven’t posted for a while….I’m a keen reader…a long while since, having previously blotted my copybook….as is said in a language I also managed to mangle…”c’est la vie”…so I’m chipping in on the Blue Mancs…odious as anything anyone has confronted since I can remember and well before that….Some Spuds may possibly think that moving from Sarf of the Thames to the place of my birth N5 (or indeed N19 where my Mum actually delivered me…God bless her) is a grievous sin (in their eye at least) but who really cares…The consensus is that they (the Blue Mancs)should be punished to the max…well I absolutely agree. However, I’m sure we all can see the massive “dummy spit” and “toys out of the pram” that will happen. How could such a wonderful organisation from Abu Dhabi (whatever they’re called) be accused of doing the wrong thing…oh and would UK and the rest of us (I’m now in OZ…year 53) when the miracle happens and Hormuz opens…would you like some oil? Albeit we don’t have a lot…but we could make it worth your while…you know…big fine for Y114/115 but please don’t send us down down down…sadly I can see this happening, in some way…Cynic or Realist?
This is an outstanding piece.
https://thenonnegotiables.substack.com/p/what-manchester-city-stole-from-us
C100
Many tks for posting..”What Manchester City Stole From Us All”…says it all
What you said…an outstanding piece
Tks again
MMTWP
Bath@67: Your caution is well placed.
C100@69: Thanks for that link. His point that we have all been robbed is incontrovertible.
A cursory reading of the English-language Gulf press reveals, unsurprisingly, restrained, perfunctory coverage, largely confined to the club’s statement that the legal proceedings continue and that it is confident of establishing its innocence. There is acknowledgement of the unprecedented scale of the allegations and potential sanctions, mainly through the publication of international wire agency reports. The story is not front-page news, but, to be fair, far bigger geopolitical issues are occupying the Gulf states at present.
M’learned friends pass on a couple of tidbits of gossip circulating in their circles. First, the scuttlebutt is that the one charge on which City was acquitted was among the most serious, which gives its legal team hope that it has a thread to tug on that will unravel more of the charges. Second, the PL will play this out absolutely by the book as City’s legal team will also jump on any procedural or legal errors. Getting the charges thrown out on technical rather than substantive grounds is seen as City’s best line of attack from here on in, a replay of how it got UEFA’s charges dismissed previously, although it can’t play the statute of limitations card in this case.
Superb piece there, C100 @69.
https://cannoniq.substack.com/?utm_source=navbar&utm_medium=web
I hope I have copied this article which is also excellent on the fallout from C114y’s perfidy .I am grateful to C100 for sharing the article @69 which is superb. This article is very well worth reading as well.
For a large part of my time on here I was critical of Arsene Wenger and his inabilit6 t9 recapture the glories of his early tenure . This article underlines what an incredible job he did and how bitter he must feel as C114y’s guilt is uncovered .Juergen Klopp too a man who competed manfully with the biggest cheats in football history .
I have been very hawkish on this issue since it started and couldn’t agree that it would be swept under the carpet nor do I think C114y will escape with a rap on the knuckles because of their financial power and diplomatic chicanery .
When that news broke on Friday everything changed . Even if every charge was subsequently dropped football worldwide knows what happened at the Etihad during the years under investigation. It skewed the way teams competed and it skewered them and whatever ADUG seek to do the football worldwide now knows what they are about. I know several City fans who are deeply ashamed by this verdict and the atmosphere when the team reassemble won’t be like the one George Graham stoked up in 90/91 .
The world knows they cheated and the club they play for has lost the respect of the football world . They aren’t coming back from this
Great piece @69, thanks C100 and also thanks to TTG @76
for the link and an excellent post on the implications of C114y’s
sustained cheating. Many across the football world have been
robbed, including us.
MMTWP – good to see you back in the bar. Born in the Whittington, eh?
C100@69 – Excellent piece. Thank you for posting. Off to read TTG @76.
TTG @76, that’s a superb and very well thought out piece.
It sums it all up really. We have lived through and been repeatedly frustrated and disappointed by a sustained period of grand larceny.
I do still fear that a further disappointment may be that the felons and their crime network escape natural justice.
I do hope that Wenger and Klopp see the day when they can open the most expensive champagne available to celebrate the public defenestration of that awful organisation and its prize villains.
Bath
I think you are in the ‘ can’t believe it’s really going to happen ‘ camp. There must be a very severe punishment for C114y. They won’t escape . The previous stance of the CBIRGTH was to believe they wouldn’t be found guilty . But they have because they were.Now they will be punished and it will be heavy
TTG @80, I am indeed. It’s my conditioning. I do admire your faith in the system.
G’day CER & tks
Royal Northern Hospital (now just the entrance way preserved on Holloway Roda). We lived in Nicholay Road N19 but looking it up (never thought to do so before) Royal Northern appears to be N7!
Very good piece on the views of the rest of the league about City in the Athletic this morning.
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7635582/2026/09/28/how-football-views-man-city-verdict/
MMTWP – Royal Northern long defunct unfortunately. A mate of mine had physio there back in the 80s. Tony Woodcock was in the next treatment bay! How times have changed!
Those of us familiar with the US legal system have become accustomed to the first verdict not being the final outcome, and that may inform our caution. Until we can read the independent commission’s decisions, we won’t know how strong a case City has for an appeal, or on how many charges. This is uncharted territory; the sanctions hearing and any possible appeals following it are even more so. We should be careful not to let justifiable moral outrage cloud our navigation of it.
That said, I readily acknowledge the strong and consistent position taken by TTG and others in this fine establishment that City would be held to serious account, and my own scepticism, although that is increasingly, if not completely, being dispelled.
Nonetheless, TTG@76 is right that the guilty verdict on 114 of the 115 charges changes everything in the court of public opinion, regardless of whether any or all of the charges are subsequently overturned or whatever sanctions are imposed. The football world knows what City has done and how it has ripped up the sporting integrity of the PL, harming the game and other clubs and defrauding fans.
In the modern world, cheats are no longer the pariahs they once were, but it will take City a very long time to rid itself of the taint it has brought upon itself.
C100 – thanks for @69 👏🏻👏🏻
Thanks to C100 and Ned for comments and contributions from the Athletic. I had read the Athletic article and found some of the comments very lacking in divination and insight .
I’ve done a share of scenario planning in my time and I’d suggest that there are several real threats to C114y .
One is that the New Independent Football Regulator could get involved
The Independent Football Regulator (IFR) now has specific statutory powers concerning unsuitable owners. I can’t think of many owners less suitable than one who has wracked up this number of offences! I read the majority of the Der Spiegel emails ( so others didn’t have to!) and they reveal a culture of arrogance and disdain that drove a lot of the rule breaches .
Under the Football Governance Act 2025, the IFR can:
* determine that an owner is not suitable to own a regulated club;
* direct the owner to take steps to cease being an owner;
* ultimately make an ownership removal order;
* and disqualify an individual from being an owner or director of a regulated club.
The League can also impose a points deduction ( or relegation ) on C114y and this looks both likely and justified. As Ned says the Court of Public Opinion will throw its weight behind a club that potentially has blown English football apart and anything too anaemic will not look proportionate given the fate suffered by the likes of Everton and Forest . And while there may be a gigantic financial penalty it can’t be the main route to punishment because of ADUG’s inexhaustible wealth . The League may let the Red Cartel and other aggrieved parties ( of whom there are many ) mount their own actions and focus on footballing sanctions . So the thought that C114y will shake off relegation ( perhaps a huge relegation) , keep all their superstars happy during a period of nationwide disapproval and bounce back bright eyed and bushy tailed sponsored by Netflix is a trifle fanciful.
Let’s face it – a glorious return of the biggest cheats in the history of football wouldn’t find favour as a documentary with a large number of fans . A slide into oblivion- now you are talking! And never forget this whole exercise is about projecting the glorious values of Abu Dhabi to the world . This is not a good look for a regime looking to engender admiration and envy from the rest of the world .
While I’m on my soapbox let me attach a couple of paragraphs from an article from a C114y supporter in the Guardian at the weekend . They mirror the feelings of a very good mate who used to be the CEO of my old company and has supported C114y since he was tiny . These are not the reactions you get on TalkShite where they feel the 114 charges are a mirage.
This is what intelligent and decent C114y supporters are feeling
‘ Our behaviour has been pretty outrageous at Dodge City. Failing to provide accurate and up-to-date financial reports, concealing salary details and bonuses, inflating sponsorship revenues and failing to cooperate or supply requested documents during the investigation all feature on the charge sheet. We used lawyers to royally take the piss. And when it comes down to it, that is not very City. After all, this is a club founded in 1880 as St Mark’s (West Gorton) by members of St Mark’s Church of England for humanitarian and social rescue purposes to serve the deprived area of east Manchester, where Shameless was filmed a century later.
So what happens next? We may lose trophies. We will almost certainly get relegated. We almost certainly lose our best players and say ha det bra to Erling Haaland, the great Nordic God of goalscoring (having said that he may stay just to see how many he could get in a Championship season). And we start building again.
That is the likely direction of travel
TTG @88. You need to ask your old boss why if Manchester City were such a paragon of virtue around the turn of the old century this happened.
https://www.theguardian.com/football/2020/feb/26/manchester-city-falling-foul-of-ffp-in-1906-forgotten-story?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other
TTG@87: This will be a good test of the independence of the Independent Football Regulator. My 2 cents is that No 10 will do all it can to discourage the IFR from exercising its statutory powers, as your accurately laid out above, for as long as it can, so as not to jeopardise UK-UAE relations (and, of course, the Prime Minister has good connections to the City as a result of its owners’ multi-billion redevelopment investment around the Etihad, which he touts as part of his urban rejuvenation of Manchester, but that is a separate story). I would not be surprised if the IFR’s initial position is that it will have to wait until the PL’s process and any subsequent legal battles are complete before considering whether to launch a ‘fit and proper’ investigation. Whether that position could hold up in the face of public opinion is another matter. I rather doubt that it would.
One scenario I have heard outlined is that sanctions would be multi-season but suspended or ended on a change of ownership. The first year would see a hefty points deduction, but not necessarily one that would relegate City, or would relegate them no further than the Championship (which would preserve the sporting integrity of the season’s PL and keep City a sellable asset); the sanctions would subsequently ratchet up unless ended by the arrival of new owners. It is an intriguing compromise, possibly a politically appealing get-out, but not one that would satisfy many, I suspect.
C100@89: Indeed.
See also https://www.goonerholicsforever.com/?p=7325, which starts:
And so to an FA Cup fourth-round tie at the Oillands, where the colour of money is sky blue.
There is a story that Manchester City plays in sky blue and white because when its predecessor club, Ardwick AFC, was in financial straits, Freemasons bailed it out. As a condition or a thank you for the money, the team ditched their red and black shirts for the then colours of Freemasonry. Only circumstantial evidence supports this story. Yet if it is true, the apple has never fallen far from that tree.
I know I’m a bit idealistic compared to some people in here but I continue to refuse to believe that C130y’s punishment will be decided on the basis of inter-governmental bargaining. It’s a bit late for Abu Dhabi to worry about being embarrassed in the eyes of the world – and I doubt they would base their arms purchases and therefore state security on the severity of punishment of their club football team.
Tbere will simply be too much backlash from all the other clubs who have suffered big losses if C130y are not appropriately and sufficiently punished for a decade of cheating and the subsequent years of trophy doninance achieved on that platform.
They can deny and threaten and reassure all they like. They have no evidence to magically save the day. Their exposure has come as the result of publication of their emails which have their names all over them.
Rather than break off trading relations with this country over their already established guilt, I would think it more likely they would walk away from ownership of the club. General ridicule and opprobrium is hardly the aim of sportswashing after all and City are going to be suffering plenty of that everywhere they go.
Some interesting drinks above .
C100@89
Apropos of nothing, he wasn’t my boss I was his but he went on to great things after I left the firm . He has said to me he can endure heavy points deductions and relegation but would hate them to be stripped of the title.
Ned@90/91
I think your suggestions are both very sensible and a practucsl way to deal with this. C114y seem to be trying to manage expectations that this will go on for as long as they can make it go on , probably in the hope the PL will soften their stance over time . But the Premier League will have 19 or more club owners very interested in getting this resolved and the court of public opinion will start to make life toxic for City . Set against this the dismantling of C114y with several stars moving to La Liga or Saudi Arabia will diminish the appeal of the league and it may make TV rights less attractive to the broadcast media . But moral crusades can’t be abandoned midstream and that’s what football fans will regard this as now .
Trev @92
I’m sure at this moment ADUG are sorry they ever heard of Manchester City . I hadn’t factored in the connections our PM may have after his stint as Manchester Mayor but a toxic football club reviled all over the world isn’t an asset that adds much to Abu Dhabi’s prestige . There may also be pushback about sovereign wealth funds buying clubs in future . I’ve never done significant business in the Arab world but the importance of face appears to be similar to how it plays among major Asian nations and this would suggest a strategically managed exit is on the cards
I suppose we’ll find out who has
Get out clauses in their contracts at
C114y over the coming months but
regardless I think only Haaland would
have even an impact for the PL’s appeal.
Good riddance to bad rubbish would be
my thought obviously but also we can
help along ADUG’s exit by making the
pain and humiliation last, that will be very
detrimental for the owners.
Trev@92 & TTG@93: I understand that City’s chairman, Khaldoon Al Mubarak, and Andy Burnham know each other well. Quite separately, when the Abu Dhabi royal family tried to buy the Telegraph newspaper group, the criticism they received from some sections of the UK apparently got under their skin, which did not help UK-UAE relations. It also led to the UK government banning foreign state ownership of UK media, so new limits on foreign state ownership of football clubs are not inconceivable.
And even more separately, on an admittedly limited sample of fans of Abu Dhabi’s New York team, NY City, this whole affair is water off a duck’s back here. They are very happy to see their shiny new purpose-built football stadium rise next to the Mets’ baseball field. No further questions asked about something that feels nothing to do with them — though they would take Haaland in a heartbeat if he suddenly became available. He was a social media darling when he was here for the World Cup, and would fill the new stadium to the rafters when it opens for the next MLS season.
I have wondered if there might be some ‘gentlemen’s agreements’ with some of City’s more recent signings and contract extenders in the event of worst-case scenarios materialising.
And lest we forget that City isn’t the only bad apple, our old friend Gianni Infantino is planning to spread some more FIFA largesse. Now I wonder why he would be thinking of doing that…
https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/articles/c6n4k9exz4v3o
Picks up the ball in midfield, looking for options running ahead…….
TTG @88, that’s a very different perspective from most of the noise coming from the Eastlands, their mouthpieces, official and covert and their gobby plastic fans. It’s nice to hear there are some rational Cityzens with a moral core.
But then there’s the link kindly posted by C100 @89 which reminds us of the scandalous fiscal behaviour of that club in the first decade of the 20th century and includes the fine turn of phrase:
“as if some ribbon of DNA runs through the club”.
Shameless was perhaps an accurate insight into mores in that neck of the woods.
Slips a gentle Bergkampesque through ball between two defenders to…
Runs forward and BANG!
Finely done, sir. There couldn’t be a more deserving scorer.
The invoice for the assist fee is in the post with details of the Middle Eastern bank account.
Finely and fairly crafted goal there, gents. ✅✅
Fairly being an important element in this and every case of course.
Good to see big Vik scoring for Sweden for the second time in two games.
Not quite as significant, but also nice to see Bruno score against Oz.
Well in for the ton, TTG. Deft assist, Bath.
Meanwhile, City digs in for the long haul. A great war of attrition is well underway.
https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/articles/ckz7zxzdwl7lo
ESPN reports that City was informed of the commission’s verdict in July. This raises the question of why the PL didn’t inform the other clubs until last week, with the season underway. If the PL was trying to negotiate a sanctions settlement, wouldn’t it have become clear straight away that City was being obdurate and that the PL’s own credibility depended on the commission following through with sanctions and letting the chips fall where they may? Or have City’s owners taken a leaf out of the book of their neighbours across the Gulf, believing their best bet for survival is to settle into a position of neither war nor peace with the PL?
https://www.espn.com/soccer/story/_/id/50057978/man-city-learned-guilty-verdicts-summer-transfer-splurge-sources
Jonathan Liew on the breakdown of the rule of law iunder the weight of money in football and elsewhere.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/sep/29/manchester-city-global-mega-rich-impunity
PL has confirmed City found guilty on all charges of breaking financial rules and majority of non-cooperation ones. Game on!
PL statement:
https://www.premierleague.com/en/news/4727779/premier-league-statement-manchester-city-fc
For those wanting the gory detail, here is a redacted version of the commission‘s core findiings:
https://resources.premierleague.pulselive.com/premierleague/document/2026/09/29/9bb3f063-6312-4d15-a1f1-77280d356a49/Premier-League-Manchester-City-independent-Commission-Redacted-Core-Decision.pdf
It’s time to drum them out of the Brownies. What a disgrace they are.
Sportswashing – ha!
An unbelievably strong statement. If anyone else thinks they’ll just get a massive fine, I seriously suggest you think again. Throw the proverbial book at them. In fact throw the whole British library. Then follow up with a bookshop or two.
So it was ticky tacky and not tiki taki all along?
Who knew? Pretty much everyone I imagine.
They’ll be showered with abuse everywhere they go until hard action is taken and deservedly so. I wonder if their players will be in breach of contract if they refuse to play out of disgust for the behaviour of the Milk Sheik and his cohorts?
Will the Emptihad be even emptier than usual? Or will the emptiheads just keep turning up pretending they don’t care?
What is unbelievable is the number of fans of other clubs who wanted City to beat us to the title last season. Stockholm syndrome?
A quick review of their history reveals that the Blue Bottlers have been rotten to the core since the early 1900s. Recent revelations are nothing new .
“City won the Second Division and promotion to the First Division in 1899. They won their first honour on 23 April 1904, beating Bolton Wanderers 1–0 to win the FA Cup. City narrowly missed out on a League and Cup double that season after finishing runners-up in the League. In the seasons following the FA Cup triumph, the club was dogged by allegations of financial irregularities, culminating in the suspension of seventeen players in 1906.”
I refer the honourable gentlemen to post 89. Pay attention at the back! 🤣🤣
A first read of the core findings confirms what we have long suspected: ‘sham sponsorships’ (the commission’s phrase, not mine), off the books payments, including the so-called Fordham arrangement to pay players for image rights, and knowingly inaccurate financial reports, all with the intent of circumnavigating the PL and UEFA financial rules. In addition, the commission found that City had sought to block and obstruct the PL’s investigation.
The yet-to-be published appendices to the core report, which could run to thousands of pages, will yield more detail but what we have from the core report is pretty damning, in my view, and no passage more so than this:
However, as set out principally in that Appendix 6 we concluded
a) That evidence given by a number of important factual witnesses called to give evidence on behalf of the Club was false in a number of key respects, and
b) That certain of those factual witnesses had given evidence at the hearing that they knew to be untrue and so had been dishonest.
Not just cheats, but lying cheats.
£900,000,000 under the counter …..
What does sham look like? The core report includes a helpful table. The right-hand column, Tagged Sum, represents the sham element of the sponsorship. It totals £830.7 million over the nine seasons. According to the commission, the way it worked was that the Abu Dhabi (AD) sponsor would agree the headline sponsorship figure with City (prop. Abu Dhabi United Group (ADUG), prop. Sheikh Mansour as a private individual) and pony up the base fee. The AD sponsor would then realise it had overextended itself and, cap in hand, approach the Abu Dhabi government (prop. Sheik Mansour’s family as ruling dynasty) for ‘financial assistance’ to cover the gap (the ‘tagged sum’), which, thanks to the beneficence of the ruling dynasty, it duly received so it could fulfil its obligations to City.
We did have other plans for this interlull we really did but events have overtaken us ! I think we have to keep this thread running for a while given that so many bombshells are exploding and many posters want to have their say.
My own position has changed from annoyance with City when this was first mooted to utter disgust at the character and morality of C114y which was stoked when I looked at what Der Spiegel was sharing . If you don’t have high blood pressure already you will after you read that ! And sadly as so often happens in football a large number of C114y supporters clearly don’t realise how serious this is , that not only have they been charged but they have been convicted . The penalties they must face will, as C100 suggests have to be massive . It’s a dark day for football and it has a way to go yet .
I was reminded today that City, allegedly, paid Borussia Dortmund £52M for Erling Haaland in 2022. Haaland scored 62 goals in 67 appearances for the German team, a rate of scoring he has kept up for City (117 goals in 137 appearances). I remember watching him in the champions league and thinking wow.
Anyone think this transfer fee was maybe mis stated a tad?
Lies, damn lies and reported Manchester City numbers.
TTG@121: Having read the core report from start to finish (it is only 40 pages; the appendices are a treat to come), I find myself sharing your direction of travel. The original emails leaked by Der Spiegel revealed a group of men accustomed to getting their own way with impunity and at any cost. The dispassionate legalese of the core report, written, I assume, by a senior judge (the names of the three commission members are redacted), is, if anything, even more chilling in its cold portrayal of systematic, deliberate deception and dishonesty.
As the report implies at one point, regardless of the merits of any individual charge, collectively they represent a continuum of conduct.
I am not a lawyer and obviously haven’t read the unpublished appendices, but, on the face of it City does not have strong grounds for appeal. The report states blunty: The conclusions that we reached were that
a) The Club’s challenges to the PL’s ability to bring the Charges failed
b) None of the matters raised by the Club provided it with a defence to any of the
Charges.
However, a footnote to b) says Although as set out in those Appendices certain matters raised by the Club do operate to reduce the extent/degree of the Club’s breaches of the PL Rules in certain respects.
That may be a loose thread for City’s lawyers to pull on, as may be the minority of the non-cooperation charges on which City was acquitted. We shall see. City has until October 2 to file an appeal.
My fear is that if City doubles down on defending itself to the bitter end, it will be forced to go nuclear. I am not sure what that would look like. It could range from dragging the PL and its clubs through the courts in a prolonged, knock-down, last-man-standing legal fight to bankrolling a new Super League. None of that would be good for English football.
.
If anyone watched the Czech Republic v England game on ITV to the end, they will have seen Roy Keane and Ian Wright discussing the City findings.
Roy Keane said “If I had won those trophies with City during that period, I would be throwing my medals in the bin”
It so happens that I know, slightly, someone who works on football for ITV sport and was working for them on the show tonight (she sits two rows in front of me on the North Bank).
I commented to her on social media that I admired the comment. She replied “ You should have heard them behind the scenes – what they said was much worse! 👀“
C100@122: As I remember, City got Haaland on the cheap as he had a ridiculously low release clause in his Dortmund contract, which they triggered.
Ned. Really? You don’t think others wanted Haaland but City didn’t sweeten the deal and just not report it? I’m very unconvinced. Wonder what they paid him v what they reported?
Where City is concerned don’t believe what you read.
Ned @125 – this might help to explain –
https://x.com/kosisovall/status/2104578625781563519?s=48
TTG – seems I’ve been way ahead of you in getting to “utter disgust” for C114y / C130y.
I saw some of the stuff reported in Der Spiegel, with copies of emails, a few years ago now. Hence my belief that this saga all had to result in more than a negotiated slap on the wrist if the league were to retain any semblance of credibility.
Trev
I’ve been trying to comvince a number of Holics that C114y were in deep trouble for a long time . I think several very knowledgeable Gooners on here understood the financial and legal chicanery very well but there was a strong thread of ‘ if City get hammered it will be too good to be true ‘.
Seeing Soriano on TV tonight making that internal video for city employees it was astonishing that he can maintain so vehemently their innocence when this “irrefutable evidence “signally failed to convince the three independent legal experts on the commission.
Lisa Nandy , the Minister responsible for sport in the government seemed very determined to push through appropriate punishment as quickly as possible. Soriano clearly wants to drag this out as far as possible but there may come a time when, especially if there is a backlash from C114y supporters who are disillusioned and disgusted with the way the Club has been run and the shame it has brought to the Club., that public opinion willl force them to try to come to an agreement with the Premier League .
I don’t see how the Abu Dhabi owners can continue to run the Club given the frankness of the Premier League report tonight. It is a shit show of epic proportions
Trev@127: Do you have the source quote from Kehl about the side deals? I can’t find anything remotely like it. There would be some European regulators and authorities most interested in picking up that conversation if he really said that on the record.
I did find some credible reports that City paid around £35 million in signing bonuses to Haaland and fees to his agent, on top of the transfer fee. (City declared agents’ fees of £51.6 million in the financial year in which they bought Haaland.) Throw in a five-year contract worth £75 million plus the usual bonuses and image rights deals for a player like that, and you could get to a total cost to City of around £200 million for his acquisition, but most of that would be negotiated with Haaland’s agents, not Dortmund.
In looking for the Kehl quote, I did find reports from 2022 saying that Haaland’s agents had carefully structured his career path, and that they had insisted on the relatively low release clause when Dortmund bought the young Norwegian from Red Bull, so that when a deep-pocketed big club did come calling, they, not the selling club, would be the ones running the auction for his services. Dortmund was a complaint but well-remunerated stepping stone, with whom City had no need to do secret side deals. His agents, a different matter, of course.
No idea if that is true, but it seems the more plausible story.
More Miguel Delaney:
It seems there were tiny little testing the water Cheaty steps at the
beginning and then. once it all seemed jolly fun and easy peasy, C114y
graduated to great leaps forward into deeper cesspits. Then when the
stench attracted attention, it was all “nothing to smell here, move along
everyone”. What a mess; I suppose, like Infantino, C114y can try to
drag it out but they are dead in the water to me and I see no way back
for the current ownership given their obviously criminal behavior.
Thanks for all the links everyone.
It appears that the C114y motto as above is “Superbia in pro Elia”, which they choose to render as “ Pride in Battle”. Superbia in my experience is more often translated as “arrogance”, actually. How very apt.
That should be “Superbia in Proelia”.
Interestingly, proelia is plural. Whoever dreamed up this particularly piece is doggerel clearly knew what was to come.
I am also not entirely convinced that it shouldn’t be the singular “proelio”, in the ablative case. As with so much that C114y do, the role and meaning of words they choose seems to be entirely dependent on what they would like them to do and mean. E.G. “ a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence exists in support of all of its positions in this case”.
Ned@123 et al- I have now read the 40 page core report. I would advise everyone to do so. It is not an overly difficult read. There is a great deal of redaction. And as with many such legal documents, a great deal of repetition as the same form of words is used multiple times in the description and, ultimately, rejection of the defence case.
What a read through does is show just how unambiguously and unequivocally the Independent Commission rejected the defence. Some of the language is starkly dismissive and, to my non-legally trained mind, more strongly put than I would have imagined. They call out the defence case as indefensible. The defence witnesses – the ones not appearing as experts, but as material witnesses- as untrustworthy.
As for the one charge that they find for, I’m not convinced it is a genuine legal thread to pull on. This seems to be that some of the actions City took were actually, genuinely, in pursuance of cost reduction. That strikes me as simply a common sense thing to do. Whereas removing costs by creating fictitious – “scam” in the words of the report – agreements to sell media rights is the antithesis of this, as well as being fraudulent misrepresentation, I would think. I can’t see how this one, tiny partial upholding of part of a charge can possibly untie the rest of the case dismissal. But we all know that won’t stop these serial cheats, with their clear utter disregard and abhorrence of the host culture which has allowed them to operate, from trying. Again, I urge you all to read the core document, which can be found as a link in the PL statement in their website.
And I can’t wait for the detailed appendices to be made public. They promise to be utterly damning. Further, I suspect these may be dropped in piecemeal fashion. This to my mind would be a great tactic to keep the detail coming in order to fight off the Abu Dhabi buying off of legacy media client “journalists” which has contributed so heavily to the public lack of questioning of City’s mores and growth since 2009.
In the Guardian this morning Jonathan Wilson doesn’t sugar coat it.
“… The Premier League is made up of its 20 constituent clubs. City have cheated each of the other 19. They have lied consistently and deliberately. The continued denials only enhance the sense that this is a club that has no respect for the regulations…”
https://www.theguardian.com/football/2026/sep/29/manchester-city-financial-breaches-verdict-premier-league?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other
U
Ned – I don’t personally do Twitter / x, so I have no further info other than the link I posted. Someone has since told me it could be fake – that’s why I don’t bother with the thing, it is very difficult to know exactly what you’re looking at. However, that story would be entirely in keeping with the rest of their behaviour whether it’s true or not.
CER@136: Every word!
Trev@139: I’m pretty sure it is fake. The broader point is true: City was a known honeypot. Fingers were sticky and hands not necessarily clean.
So happy that City’s first game back will be at Anfield. Looking forward to the sympathetic welcome they will surely receive.
Ned @141
We know what you are
We know what you are
You cheating bastards
We know what you are!
>>>>>>>>>>>>>