Feed on
Posts
Comments

I started writing this preview with what I thought was a very clever construct: it started with the Lydian chromatic tonal organization concept in Jazz to Lydian mode to the ancient kingdom of Lydia (in modern Anatolia) to Leeds, but there was no way I could squeeze in even the wildest linguistic theory connecting the etymology of Lydia (apparently named after Ledus the king, as per Herodotus) to Leeds, which derives its name from the old Brittonic Lātēnses, meaning “violent”, most likely in reference to the river Aire. So, rest assured, this preview will not contain the annoying preambles about non-footballing esoterica.

I have never been to Leeds, or anywhere really in west Yorkshire, and so have never noticed whether their rivers are violent or not. And given that I am not remotely English, it would be unfair of me to comment/joke on the modern relevance of the city’s ancient name. But thanks to more experienced ‘Holics in this forum, I do know about the violent history of the “Dirty Leeds” and an old enmity with the Gunners which probably still flows in the waters of Aire and Thames.

But these are different times, Daniel Farke is as far from Don Revie as is Rhine-Westphalia from Yorkshire. He had spent a few up and down years with his previous club Norwich City before going back home, and then after being sacked by Mönchengladbach, he returned back to England in 2023 to join the then newly relegated Leeds United.

Following last year’s title winning run in the Championship, Leeds are back in the PL. And after a tumultuous start to the season, they are lately doing remarkably well and notwithstanding their current league position, they are one of the in-form teams. You don’t believe me? These are their last few league results: 1-1(A) v Everton, 1-0 (H) v Fulham, 3-4 (A) v Newcastle, 1-1 (H) v Man United, 0-0 (A) v Liverpool, 1-1 (A) v Sunderland, 4-1 (A) v Crystal Palace.

I haven’t seen them play since our home match against them earlier in the summer, when we had put in a cheerfully dominating performance (I remember the players smiling a lot) to continue our flawless start with a 5-0 victory. Timber and Gyökeres both scored a brace, Saka one, and the talented highschooler Max Dowman got his league debut. A 5-0 this weekend would do nicely, pleasantly surprised though I think we all Arsenal fans would be.

Leeds were away from the PL limelights for a considerable time, before the mad (arguably) genius (and ever quotable) Marcelo Bielsa had brought his feverish press-and-pass-and-move-and-press football to England and got Leeds promoted. English is not quite his language, so quoting some of his wisdoms/absurdities – for they tend to be indistinguishable – translated from his native tongue:

“A person is a madman until his ideas triumph.”
“I know that support is only given by triumph. Almost all coaches are losers, and that’s why we are so lonely.”

And, to sum his footballing philosophy up, “The only way I understand football is constant pressure, playing in the opponent’s half, and ball possession. I am obsessed with attacking. I watch videos to attack, not to defend. Do you know what my defensive job is? We all run.”

The laid back and not entirely unlikeable (especially given that unlikeable is the middle name of all opposition managers, at least to me) Farke may not be quite so dogmatically offensive-minded, but his teams tend to try to play more creative football than any attritional approach even against oppositions superior on paper. A deep and low block of defenders covering every passing route and marking every runner off the ball is not something Arsenal would likely face. Without implying any criticism of the team or the manager, but simply as an observation I think it is fair to say we don’t quite flourish against such attritional tactics. Even then, earlier in the first half of the season, we had typically managed to find some kind of tactical-technical solution to the most obdurate of opposition defenses. The solutions haven’t always been aesthetically the most elegant, but they have been mightily effective. Until very recently.

Our last few PL results: 2-3 (H) v Man United, 0-0 (A) v Nottingham Forest, 0-0 (H) v Liverpool, 3-2 (A) v Bournemouth, 4-1 (H) v Aston Villa, 2-1 (H) v Brighton.

That dip in PL form just around the start of the year – in the three cup competitions we played in that time we have maintained our winning run, though at times exhibiting a similar dip in performances or consistency – has manifested in both ends of the pitch: failing to create enough goalscoring opportunities, and giving away goals through defensive sloppiness.

While the drop in creativity is not entirely unexpected, it is the unlikely loss of defensive solidity that has equally hurt our point tallies. Fatigue – physical and psychological, especially after a strenuous winter schedule – is a likely cause for both. At least much more likelier in my opinion than any intrinsic glitches in our tactical approach.

But let us not overemphasize on the recent results and the dip in form, which is but inevitable. We have a (fingers crossed) mostly healthy squad, both deep and diverse, and with players of different profiles complementing each other, and all driven by uncompromising work ethic and desire for personal & collective excellence. A lot has already been written about the manager Mike Arteta and his team of superlative coaches, their attention to details, their unwavering commitment to prepare the teams for all tactical and technical tools, and bringing the team’s level back up-to where they were before the holidays, and then improving further from there would now be the focus.

Leeds had started the season with a structured 4-3-3 or 4-3-2-1 formation that was meant to rely on structured build-up through the middle. However, following the troubled start to the season, Farke has shifted to a more robust and yet attack-minded 3-5-2 or 3-4-2-1 formation which has offered greater positional stability and a more pronounced directness in attack. The positional stability also enabled Leeds to employ more aggressive pressing, likely an inheritance from the Bielsa days, and aggressive pressing done right is often the surest way to earn defensive stability. However, for their last away game they played in 3-5-2 formation, with the impressive Ethan Ampadu controlling the proceedings at the heart of the midfield. Calvert Lewin and Aaronson played the two strikers. Ao Tanaka came on later in the match as a substitute, we might see him start next to Ampadu.

This would be a test for Arsenal, and anything less than our best would very likely see us lose points away, especially given the recent form Leeds are enjoying. On the other hand, if we can regain our defensive solidity, confidence on the ball, the sharpness from the dead-ball situations, we should be able to assert our overall technical and physical superiority and dominate the game effectively enough for a difficult, but ultimately well-earned win.

The starting eleven is not as easily predictable as it was earlier in the season, thanks to a healthier state of affairs in the squad (fingers crossed, once again). Raya, Saliba, Gabriel, Timber, Zubimendi, Rice and Saka are the likeliest to return to the starting eleven. From the rest, Ødegaard too is likely to start. However, I wonder if Mikel will be tempted to start with either Kai or Merino on the right sided number eight role as a more physical presence in the midfield and in the opposition box arriving just behind the front three. Neither of them may be as press-resistant as the captain, but they are both capable of scoring goals and providing through balls. Martin is yet to hit his peak form this season, and it may not be a bad idea to allow him a breathing space to regain it.

I would like to see Nørgaard on the bench, who I think brings in stability, composure and PL know-how and can be used more and not have Zubimendi play every minute of every league match. We have missed Calafiori in the left back role, especially his contributions in the opposing half. He did look a bit rusty in the midweek CL match, and if he isn’t fully fit yet I would start with MLS. Hincapié is definitely a better defender, and not a slouch on the ball either, but he is yet to fully come to terms with the roaming left back role which is a key piece of our tactical flexibility.

My preferred starting line-up:
Raya
Timber – Saliba – Gabriel – Calafiori
Ødegaard – Zubimendi – Rice
Saka – Jesus – Trossard

Later in the second half, we may see the Kai-Gyökeres combination used again to replace Martin and Jesus. Yes, it was merely Kairat Almaty, but the way they were used in the midweek and how they played close to each other looked to be a very intentional approach, and something the manager feels offers us another variation in attack. Let us start strong, quieten the crowd, control the tempo and possession, be composed on the ball, win the 50-50s and we should create enough chances to score a couple of goals towards a 2-0 away win.

Come on Arsenal!

Arsenal became the first team to win all of their group games since UEFA revamped the group stage of the Champions League, with a 3-2 win over Kairat Almaty who are the best team from Kazakhstan that I’ve seen.

 I must crave your indulgence with this report as a change to our train timetable meant that, had I stayed to the final whistle, I would have been an hour and a half later home than if I’d missed the last ten minutes. I’ve managed to catch the highlights of that period on the train, so you’ve missed none of the action but as the last ten minutes featured a disallowed goal for Gabriel Jesùs and a headed goal for Kairat by Ricardinho I think my early exit was a portentous move.

 Pre-match I had the privilege of a drink with BtM and Bath although Bath was partaking of Bovril, not a bad choice on a January night! 

Arteta picked almost a complete second string to face Kairat with Havertz returning to start a game for the first time in many months. Calafiori also started – at centre back – and Eze and Nørgaard joined Havertz in midfield – or was that Havertz’s position? See later!

 The game began at a frantic pace and we were ahead after just over a minute. Kai showing Kairat that his long lay- off had not left any signs of Kai rot, threaded a ball through to Gyökeres who ran onto it, moved it to the right and bent it past the Kairat keeper who was irate at the lack of cover (couldn’t find a K for that one).

 Arsenal 1 Kairat 0 – Gyokeres, 1 min

No sooner were we toasting (metaphorically) this breakthrough when a nasty VAR notice appeared on the screen for a penalty review against Arsenal. After a visit to the screen the ref awarded the penalty which Jorginho despatched past Kepa. Jorginho looked very different from when he played for us but that’s life in Kazakhstan for you!

 Arsenal 1 Kairat 1 – Jorginho, penalty, 6 mins

We are making a habit of letting sides with an xG of not very much score against us but the game had an open feel to it and we were soon ahead again.

Havertz was playing in an advanced role which seemed to increase the threat from both him and Gyökeres and he showed pace, control and a fierce left-foot finish to restore our lead after he and Gyökeres chased a ball threaded forward by captain for the night, Ben White.

Arsenal 2 Kairat 1 – Havertz, 16 mins

 We were notably more dangerous albeit that Kairat were playing a high line that verged on the disastrous. Eze, Madueke and Martinelli caught the eye, Gyökeres missed some presentable chances and MLS combined with Martinelli in an incisive left wing move.

Our third goal came when Havertz turned the ball across and Martinelli
made a better job of finishing the pass than Gyökeres. It was immediately disallowed for offside call on Havertz but you can’t trust these identical twins on the line and after another thrilling VAR review the goal was given.

 Arsenal 3 Kairat 1 – Martinelli, 36 mins

 Arsenal’s fluidity was pleasing but they were wasteful in finishing and the overall impression at the end of the first half was that we hadn’t fully emphasised our superiority.

 Half Time – Arsenal 3 Kairat 1

Havertz and Calafiori were withdrawn at halftime for Ødegaard and Hincapié. Ødegaard was diligent but failed to finish a couple of very basic headed chances and Kairat who defended notably deeper found it easier to repel us, although we created plenty of chances. Martinelli and Madueke had their fullbacks on a piece of string but we couldn’t capitalise. Jesùs replaced Havertz and Brandon Bailey-Joseph made his first team debut to relieve Martinelli.  Later, Ife Ibrahim also made a late debut. Jesus had a late effort disallowed for offside and then Ricardinho nodded home from close range to create a very misleading scoreline.

Arsenal 3 Kairat 2 – Ricardinho 90+2 mins

Full time – Arsenal 3 Kairat 2

Arsenal fans should be very proud of our achievement of gaining a 100% record from a schedule that included four tricky away games and two home games against European giants in Bayern Munich and Atletico Madrid
But not the two entitled idiots I met on the tube before the match who described our form as ‘terrible’. Plastic fans like those two are intensely irritating and help to create what can be an underwhelming atmosphere in the ground. 

Tonight was a strange game with zero jeopardy but some exciting football. I was impressed with Mosquera and Eze. Madueke combines brilliance with a regularly errant final ball, Gyökeres showed us what he is capable of with a fine finish and a number of misses from straightforward opportunities but the big dividend from the night was the return of Havertz who brought real quality to our attacking play. At the moment, I’d choose a fully fit Havertz above Ødegaard in the ‘right eight’ position.

So, our next European involvement will come in March when we will find out just how good we are. The presence of five English clubs in the top eight underlines the strength of the Premier League and that is where we must now turn our attention.

Kairat Almaty

A 24 Kairat Gold Performance Please, Reds!

On Wednesday evening, in what seems this busiest of seasons, we welcome Kairat Almaty to the Emirates for the final round of Champions League league-phase matches. The Arsenal stand proudly at the pinnacle of the league table and, barring a mathematical catastrophe, are guaranteed to finish there with a perfect record. Kairat, on the other hand, sit rooted to the bottom of the table, although curiously only separated from a team like Villarreal by a four goals inferior goal difference. This must be due to the vagaries of the “new” draw. Perhaps it says something about the new format being less predictable – or maybe Villarreal are just having a very poor season?

As I’m sure we’re all now well aware, a major benefit of finishing in one of the top two positions is that we will play at home in the 2nd leg of every knockout round right up to the final – or as far as we might have the good fortune to go. In any event this match appears to be the very definition of a dead rubber. It will be interesting to see how close to capacity the ground looks but it could well be a quiet night for Kairat’s own version of a ticket super tout, Kazakh Stan. 

Thankfully, from a travel point of view, the game is at home and will save our fans an arduous trip to Kazakhstan. It should also leave them less exposed to the attentions of the Almaty Ultras – or the Kairat Crunchers as they are known – albeit mostly to themselves.

I will be forever grateful to my dad for taking me to my very first Arsenal game and making me a Gooner. He knew I was consumed by football but had only a passing interest in it himself. As a result our trip to Highbury turned out to be a one off but I was hooked – amazed by the lights, the size and the magic of the occasion. So I was even more amazed to discover that, even all those years ago, as far as his “fandom” went, my dad was a Kairat Almaty supporter. He was an extremely keen gardener but had neither the inclination nor the skills required for DIY. But on several of those occasions when forced into a bit of repair work, I heard him yelling “Kairat Almaty!” from the shed as another misdirected hammer blow found the end of his thumb.

The Opposition
Kairat Almaty was founded in 1954 under the name Lokomotiv Alma-Aty as a works team representing the local railway company. After a series of mergers dictated variously by politics and the agricultural employment sphere to which its expanding membership belonged, the club adopted the name Kairat Almaty in 1956. Kairat is a Kazakh word with Arab roots meaning “strength, courage, vitality and fighting spirit”, and is the romanised version of the name of its owner, Qairat Boranbayev, a Kazakh businessman.

The club is comfortably the most successful in Kazakhstan, having won four league titles, eight Kazakhstan Cups and two Kazakhstan Super Cups in what is described as its modern history. During the Soviet era, Kairat Almaty became a symbol of Kazakh football at national level.

The club has undergone several phases of development in its time but, while I always enjoy and admire North Bank Ned’s superb histories of our upcoming opponents, I have neither the time nor desire to impose similar detail on you about Kairat Almaty. The following excerpt from their particular history will hopefully explain why and has been lifted from Wikipedia if you really can’t resist: “The 1971 season was highly successful for the club. Under Viktor Korolkov’s rule, Kairat finished 8th in the Top League, a significant increase compared to previous seasons. On 12 November 1971, Kairat won the European Railworks Cup, defeating Rapid Bucharest 2–1 in the final.” That’s quite enough of that!

During the break up of the Soviet Union they reportedly appointed Mikhail Gorbachev as Director of Football. He achieved little, in truth, but did at least manage to find them a perestroikas.

The three most famous players who played for Kairat – and in all probability the only ones anyone here will ever have heard of – are our very own erstwhile winger Andrey Arshavin, former Bayern Munich midfielder Anatoliy Tymoshchuk and Brazilian striker Vagner Love. They do currently have a 28 year old No 7 called Jorginho but he is nothing to do with any of the similarly named players that might just spring to mind. Neither is he Brazilian – being in fact a Bissau-Guinean.

The club is actually quite stable with almost all of the coaching staff having been in place since around 2019. The exception to the rule is their manager, Rafael Urazbakhtin, who was appointed more recently, in September 2024, and is apparently well known for his cairat and stick coaching methods.

For the technically inclined, according to the club’s website, Kairat play in a 4-4-2 or a 4-3-3, or a 4-2-3-1 “for defensive stability and attacking creativity”. It seems pretty rudimentary information, should cover all bases, and whichever one they choose will hopefully prove utterly futile against our table topping superstars.

The Arsenal
On the injury front we have to wait and see whether Ricardo Calafiori is deemed fit enough to make the squad. He’s been out since pulling up in the warm-up before the win against Brighton just after Christmas. That must have been some warm up as he’s now missed nine games across all competitions with the resulting muscle injury. He was spotted in training ahead of the Manchester United game and Arteta said he could be available for selection. He wasn’t selected in the event so eyes will now be on Wednesday evening.

Kai Havertz also failed to make the matchday squad on Sunday. There were suggestions on social media that there are concerns over the German, but Arteta has reassured Arsenal supporters that he is “very close” to full fitness.

He said: “Obviously, he has been out for a long time, almost a year, for different reasons, and now we have to be very smart in the manner that we manage that load, the minutes.

“I am sure in the next few weeks he is going to play minutes. I cannot tell you which competition because that will depend as well on the game context, and it is a context that is positive to throw him in or not, with his qualities.

“It is great that we have him. We can use him in different positions. We will see him in different positions, and we are really happy to have him.”

Personally, I would love to see him in positions other than supine or prone on the treatment table. Fingers crossed.

Max Dowman has been out since suffering an ankle ligament injury in a behind-closed-doors game against Manchester United before Christmas. The 16-year-old was ruled out for two months and has consequently been removed from Arsenal’s Champions League squad. Arteta confirmed recently that Dowman was still “a few weeks away”.

Ethan Nwaneri has now completed his loan to Marseille and scored on his debut with a trademark Nwaneri goal – a run through the right side of midfield, turning inside to curl a left footer from distance inside the far post. If it works well for him, I do wonder if he might spend next season there too. He appears a different, less extroverted character than Miles Lewis-Skelly and this loan is probably as much about his personal development as it is about football. In 18 months he can grow physically and mentally, and the overcrowded pathway into our midfield might be starting to thin out a bit by then. He’ll be joining Jurrien Timber’s twin brother, Quentin, there too. Maybe, one day, they will return to Arsenal together.

Last week Gabriel Jesùs spoke of his own pride at scoring twice in the San Siro but also took a moment to acknowledge his striking comrades: “I was so happy that Vik came on and scored a goal because a striker without a goal is always difficult. I have been fighting with this all my career, but still, I’m so happy that I scored, Vik scored, and then I’m 100% sure when Kai has the chance, he will score and help us as well.” 

Nice touch. We all hope so. Very much.

That brings us to the question of team selection. There has to be a mixture of rest, rotation and a chance of playing time and confidence restoration for some of our squad members. Declan Rice and Mikel Merino are suspended so my guess / preference would be:

Kepa;

White, Mosquera, Hincapié, MLS;

Nørgaard, Eze, Jesùs;

Madueke, Gyökeres, Martinelli.

  • with hopefully some playing time for at least Calafiori and Havertz as subs on 60-70 minutes. 

Whoever plays, this has been a tremendous Champions League campaign with brilliant wins against Bayern Munich, Atletico Madrid and Inter Milan. This team deserves everyone’s support despite whatever frustrations and anxieties we might currently be experiencing. Sticking together is the only way we can help.

And finally, at this time of year, a note to particularly any Scottish, or Chinese, Holics – a couple of my mates were throwing a joint Chinese New Year and Burns Night party on Sunday. It was called Chinese Burns night. I didn’t want to go but they twisted my arm 😉
Enjoy the game, all !

There will be a lot of nonsense spoken and written in reaction to an infuriating loss to Man Utd at home today. I am not interested in using a crazy, one-off game to make sweeping judgements about our season. All teams lose matches. We haven’t got a god given right to win. We’ve had a lot of good days this season and were probably due a shocker. Let’s take it with good grace and the knowing smile of a team on our way to winning the league anyway.

There will be some lessons to learn in terms of how we conceded three goals for the first time in a long time, and Arteta will get the video out and talk the lads through them. For us fans though, I reckon we scrunch this one up, throw it in the bin, and don’t lose sight of the fact that we are winning in four competitions right now.

The match itself was a strange one. We started much the brighter, took control of the ball and forced a series of corners which Manure generally defended well, Lammens looking solid at dealing with balls dropped into the six-yard box. Zubi had a deflected header saved, and I was just saying that we needed to make our dominance count when we scored in the 28th minute. Hincapie swung a deep cross in, Dorgu headed it up, Saka took it down beautifully and laid a lovely chip into the captain whose first time shot was creeping wide until it clipped Martinez’s heal and went in under pressure from our occasional centre-forward Jurrien Timber.

We deserved the lead, we were in control, and Manure only looked dangerous when we were sloppy in possession and almost let Mbeumo in a couple of times. All should have been serene but we did not learn our lesson and tighten up our passing. With less than ten minutes until half time Zubi received the ball from a slightly under pressure Saliba and his attempted back pass went straight to Mbeumo, who rounded Raya and scored.

The thing is, and this might not be the most subtle piece of analysis, that’s the game right there. Of course, we absolutely could have gone on to win anyway. But, without us gifting them a goal from nothing, our opponents were simply not going to win this one from a goal down. This mistake ultimately cost us three points. Easy to say with hindsight, and I must admit at the time I was annoyed but still expected us to win. I’ve got no notes for Zubi, who has been brilliant all season and knows what he did, but I do have a request. He coughed one up against Spurs that did not end up costing us, and one today that did. No more, please, Martin.

We did not start the second half well, and that is a source of regret. It was the red devils who came out looking fired up and after five minutes Patrick Dorgu scored a screamer from outside the box. Nothing much to say, it’s a great finish and the kind of chance you’d be thrilled to limit the opposition to on a regular basis. But every now and again they fly in. Bloody frustrating, but that’s football. Which rather sums our day up.

We had time on our side, but we weren’t creating clear chances and United looked like they could hurt us on the break as we had to take some positional chances. Arteta made four subs before the hour mark, looking to change the pattern of the game, but they didn’t make a huge difference.

In the seventy-first minute Merino hit a shot that a lunging Maguire took all the sting out of with his hand, and it went through to Lammens. It was a blatant penalty, a clear handball from a shot on target. The ball refused to go out of play for a couple of minutes afterwards, but I was sure that when it did, we were gonna see Pawson sent to the screen by VAR. In the end, he was not. I don’t get it. That’s a penalty. Sometimes you need a bit of luck, or, at least, the correct decision. We didn’t get either today.

We laboured on. Plenty of desire but heavy legs and loose passing hampering our efforts. We won plenty of corners and finally made one count when Merino bundled a scrappy one home. Game on.

The crowd were up for it, we all wanted to see a final ten minutes of pressure from us. How big would a winner have been at that point? Well, we got to find out, but it came at the wrong end. Rice lost the kind of challenge he normally eats up, the ball squirting through him and arriving at Cunha in far too much space. “GET TO HIM!” I bellowed at the tv, but did our players listen? Did they sausages. The former Wolves man struck a lovely finish past Raya from outside the box to put the game beyond us.

So, two excellent finishes from positions which a team would normally be thrilled to score one goal from. And a gift from us. That’s how we lost. There will be a temptation to analyse the ever-loving out of this one. Madueke’s entrance saw us put Saka on the left wing where he didn’t do much. Was this the time to try that out? Ødegaard was quiet. Rice a blend of determination and sloppiness. And plenty of other talking points besides. Perhaps some of that analysis will be quite useful going forward. But, right now, I am not going to rewatch the game to mine the analytic gold when I still have the mild nausea that comes from watching us throw away a result, empowering a poor United side to perform as well as they can and leave our ground with three points we gift wrapped for them.

As long as our players use this as a lesson about maintaining the ‘foggin estandards’ then I have no further interest in the ninety-minute nightmare we went through earlier.

We are still the best team. I still expect us to win the league. I don’t want to spend my Sunday rending garments and claiming the sky is falling. It was just a crap day at the office.

Uuurrrrrggghhh. Horrible!

But, they happen. Screw it up. Throw it in the bin. Move on!

Until next time, ‘holics. 

And so to the Stadium of Stone, where we welcome, in the ironic sense of the word, Manchester United for Sunday’s late afternoon game, after three wins and a draw away in four competitions.

It will be the 102nd time we have hosted them for a home league match since Newton Heath first travelled to the Plumstead enclosure, as the Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News called it, to be beaten 3-2 by Woolwich Arsenal in March 1895. Our Scottish international centre-forward Robert Buchanan “headed the ball through the Newton goal from a scrimmage, thus giving the Arsenal their winning point,” the publication reported. Memo to Mr Jover: In football, there’s little new under the sun.

After Amorin

Our visitors will arrive greatly uplifted by their victory last weekend over their crosstown rivals under their latest interim manager, Michael Carrick. Shall we see the team that battered the Oil-landers with such combative vim and vigour, or will the wheel of false dawns that blighted the Red Mancs under Rubin Amorim before he was given the heave-ho, turn once more?

Carrick is a go-to for United when they sack a manager. Their former player was caretaker after Jose Mourinho received his special P45 in 2018, and when Ole Gunnar Solskjær faced the same fate in 2021. While he did not manage any games after Mourinho, post-Solskjær, Carrick defeated Unai Emery’s Villarreal, drew with Thomas Tuchel’s Chelsea, and beat Mikel Arteta’s Arsenal. 

After failing to be promoted from caretaker to interim — Ralf Rangnick got the job, a decision as idiosyncratic as the choice — Carrick went off to become head coach of Middlesbrough in the Championship. In three seasons, he transformed them from relegation candidates into a team with expectations of promotion back to the Premier League. Having fallen just short of achieving that, he was sacked last July.

At the Riverside and during his previous spell at the OT, Carrick employed a 4-2-3-1 formation that morphed into a 3-2-5 in possession and a 4-4-2 midblock when out of possession. There is nothing groundbreaking in that; a zillion English clubs play that way. Carrick’s twist was to use one of his full-backs, making late runs and early crosses, as the fifth attacker.

On Teeside, he had only one player well suited to the role, and that player was on loan for one season. In the lee of the Manchester Ship Canal, he has one for each side in Amad Diallo and Patrick Dorgu, plus wide forwards in Brian Mbueno, Matheus Cunha and Mason Mount, who are comfortable both dropping deep and cutting inside, leaving the flanks open for the late overlap and fast cross.

In last weekend’s victory over City, it was hard to see that as a core principle of Carrick’s tactics. While he abandoned Amorim’s 3-4-2-1 for a back four with two defensive midfielders in front — the 4-2 element of a 4-2-3-1 — Carrick selected an attacking formation more akin to a 4 than a 3-1 to target the Achilles heel of Pep’s new pressing system.

Pep has his entire team shift to the side where the ball is to create pressing overloads. Coupled with City’s usual high defensive line, this leaves large uncovered spaces on the opposite wing. Carrick had his players firing long diagonal cross-field passes into those vacant areas whenever possible, for whoever was free to chase down and head towards goal or deliver a cutback. 

With City having 68% of possession and United defending with more conviction than they could muster under Amorim, time and time again, Man U looked to counterattack using a long pass out wide. Time and time again, they found one of their quick, powerful runners, the intentionally selected Amad, Mbuemo and Dorgu, with, as they say, acres of grass in front of them.

Carrick, who was a tactically astute player — Louis van Gaal, when his manager at United called him a coach in the game — will know that Arteta will have studied how United dismantled City. He will need to do something different on Sunday. ‘We have got our ideas on what needs to be done and how we need to get there’, he said in his pre-match press conference, slipping effortlessly into manager obfuscation mode. Back to his tried-and-trusted basics, I would expect.

The opposition

The 23-year-old Belgian, Senne Lammens, bought from Royal Antwerp in the summer for €21 million, will be glove-buttling. Dare I say it, he looks an uncommonly sensible piece of transfer business by United’s recent ker-ching standards.

Against City, Carrick replaced the young players Amorim had included in his back three, such as Leny Yoro, 20, and Ayden Heaven, 19 and formerly of this parish, and moved 23-year-old Amad from right back to his natural position as a winger. In their place, was an old-school back four comprising Harry Maguire and Lisandro Martínez at centre-back and Luke Shaw and Diogo Dalot at full-back. 

With the two Englishmen on the wrong side of 30, this is not a long-term solution. However, for now, especially with Matthijs de Ligt injured, it provides Carrick with a more experienced defence than the one that had the seventh-worst record in the league under Amorim. Nonetheless, it remains vulnerable, and I would expect de Ligt and Yoro to be starting by the end of the season. 

If Carrick were sure to be still in post next season — Man U’s omniscient higher-ups had said he will not, regardless, although the gentlemen of the turf don’t believe them; Carrick is second favourite to be the permanent appointment — I would also expect Dorgu and Amad to be groomed as the full-backs. However, Shaw will probably play most of the games this season at left back, as he will be a better third centre-back than Dorgu when United shifts into their 3-2-5. 

Unless Carrick replaces Dalot or the Moroccan Noussair Mazraoui, now back from AFCON, with Amad at right back, he will have to decide which of United’s expensively bought forwards — Mbuemo, Matheus Cunha, Benjamin Šeško and, once he returns to fitness, Joshua Zirkzee — will warm the bench so he can fit in the 23-year-old Ivory Coast international.

Carrick has also reinstated the out-of-favour Kobbie Mainoo in the pivot alongside Casemiro, who, at 33 and £350,000 a week, is not being retained for next season. Que surpresa!

Some believe the next England team should be built around Mainoo’s elite press resistance and ball-carrying skills. However, Amorim preferred Bruno Fernandes in the deep-lying playmaker role, where Mainoo could have fitted into his system. Perhaps Amorim thought nobbiness was necessary for that Paul Scholes-like role. Still, Mainoo would have left this transfer window if Amorim had not departed first.

Deploying the best players in their best positions is usually a reliable fallback for any manager. Against Man City, Carrick played Fernandes as a left-sided 10, where he likes to play. The higher up the field he is, the more threatening the Portuguese becomes to opposing defences. 

Fernandes and Mbuemo shared the false-nine duties of dropping out of the front four to receive the ball and pull a City centre half with them, creating more vacant space in behind. Saliba, who has been frequently appearing near the edge of opposition penalty areas lately, needs to be wary of being suckered into that trap. 

I expect Fernandes and Mbuemo to reprise their City roles on Sunday, with Cunha, Šeško and, let us not forget him, Mason Mount, coming off the expensively warmed bench when United are, hopefully, chasing the game. 

The Arsenal

Carrick will have his team as ‘up’ for a game against us, as it was for the City derby. Thus, I expect Arteta to start his strongest available XI, although I always do, and whether that includes Calafiori and Hincapié is anyone’s guess. Mine is that Calafiori is fit, but not Hincapié. If neither is fit, then presumably Benny Blanco comes in at right back and Timber shifts to the left rather than MLS start.

Raya

Timber, Saliba, Gabriel, Calafiori

Ødegaard, Zubimendi, Rice

Saka, Gyökeres, Trossard

Sunday’s is yet another must-win game, not least because Neville, Keane and company will be even more insufferable if we don’t. It will be a fierce scrap; these games have previous in that regard. We’ll also have to move the ball around quickly to negate our visitor’s newfound defensive industry, while cutting off the supply lines to what is a potentially potent attack. 

Do all that, and, with the home support behind the team, we can take it 2-0 to secure our first clean-sheet double over the Red Mancs since 1901-02.

Enjoy the game, ‘holics, near and far.

« Newer Posts - Older Posts »