
First Half
Hopes were high as the teams took to the pitch. That was as good as it got. Brighton started with a man for man press out of possession and we were forced into error after error, unable to hold onto the ball and giving it away time after time as we were hurried. I have never seen an Arteta team turn over the ball more times. On 31 minutes, the inevitable happened and the ball came to Groß outside the box. With nobody closing him down – in fairness while another Brighton player made a good decoy run inside him, he had time to look up and crack his shot past Raya off the inside of the post. This in no way acted as a stimulus for Arsenal who simply at no stage were at the races. Just before half time, Kostoulas scored pretty much a carbon copy of the first as we invited him to shoot from distance which he duly did, screaming one into the net. Not a single Arsenal player had a good first half. Two goals conceded from long shots invited by not pressing the man on the ball. Both excellent finishes. Arteta outthought and Arsenal outplayed.
Half Time: Brighton 2 Arsenal 0
Second Half
The second half saw no Half Time substitutions for Arsenal and no change in performance. We looked every bit as listless and enervated as we had done in the first half. Brighton continued to exhibit huge and relentless energy levels while we seemed to amble and shamble about with very little vision or purpose to our play. After 12 minutes of second half play, a corner from the left-hand side saw nobody get close to challenging Chema Andrés, who had the simple task of heading the ball into the net.
Brighton 3 Arsenal 0
Arteta threw on some subs with Zubimendi and Merino coming on for Timber and Guimarães. Merino in particular seemed to be wearing his boots on the wrong feet for the first five minutes, turning the ball over and getting caught in possession. There was no noticeable upping of the Arsenal wattage at all. The best Arsenal chance came when Gyökeres – on for a distinctly unimpressed Ødegaard – gave a very good reverse pass to Havertz, freeing him up for a one-on-one with the Brighton keeper. 21CG and I looked at one another, with the telepathic message being “there’s no way he’s scoring this”. Havertz hit his shot straight at the keeper when almost anywhere else could have resulted in a goal. The Arsenal fans began to exit. We did not get any better.
Final Score: Brighton 3 Arsenal 0.
Conclusions:
Brighton deserved their victory and were the better team by a country mile.
Not one Arsenal player came out of the game with any credit whatsoever.
Arteta was totally outthought and his team outfought.
File under B for bin.
At least we’re not Sp*rs. Although we gave a more than passable impression for 90 odd minutes today.
On to the next game.
COYG









That was a match report delivered with more urgency than the team managed today, CER. However, I did not see the game quite so negatively as you. To repeat my immediate post-match thoughts from the previous drinks, it was more a miserable day at the office, one of those when you just can’t catch a break, than a paddlin’. They scored three goals from an xG of 1.33 (0.73 from open play). We got zilch from an xG of 1.58. That two of their goals went in off a post points to ‘fine margins’. Still, we managed only two shots on target all game.
Had Saka’s in the 45th minute gone in, and we had gone in 1-1 at half-time, the result might have been different, especially as they scored their second from the clearance and before the oranges. Yet, again and again we were uncharacteristically slow to close Brighton down. There can be little argument that the home team got the bit between their teeth, and we ran second-best.
A long three weeks to reset before we play Leeds on October 10.
That’s what I saw CER. I’ve never seen so many basic individual errors. The amount of miscontrols was staggering. The ball just keep sliding under our players feet. When they did have it under control, they’d misplace the pass.
But this one might have been in the post for years now. I do not remember the last time we had one of those games where everyone was truly awful. This was it. No-one better than a 4 out of 10, generously. I’m not sure there is too much to learn. As you say CER, just put it in the bin and move on.
Ned@1 One of the great comforts of this place is that we can disagree amicably. I’m glad you can see the upside, even if I can’t. For me, this is one of the examples of statistics not telling the true story. Their keeper didn’t have a challenging save to make all day, whereas Raya had no chance whatsoever with all three of theirs and made another very good save at the end. None of our players was above a 4/10 – being generous. It’s okay though as I am now expunging the pain in my heart at our lacklustre performance. I have gone out, caught some flies and am now pulling their wings off, having baptized each one “Hurzeler”. Petty? Moi?
Dini@2 – Great minds, and mine, think alike!
Cheers, CER –
Arteta apparently remarked that he kbew something was wrong from the first throw in. I did think to myself the throw in was a mess – Raya kicked the ball straight into touch, twice – uniquely for us we seemed to have no shape all across the defence and midfield.
Lost my transmission after 4 or 5 minutes but that all set the tone.
Three weeks to stew over it now. Oh, Goodee !
Trev@5 – in that case, with 90 minutes to play, it’s a pity Arteta didn’t do something about it. That he didn’t, or couldn’t, is cause for concern.
That’s a succinct and on point report reflecting what I heard listening to the entire game on dot com and your title is superb. As I listened, it seemed that we struggled to deal with Brighton’s press, persistently turned over the ball and suffered wave after wave of attacks.
Two different Gooners who were at the game have separately told me that this match proves the unreliability of xG as a valid index of a football match. The stat tells you about the quality of accumulated chances but nothing about balance of play nor the ebb and flow of a game. It certainly sounded as if our whole team was rattled by Brighton’s ferocious start and then we lost goals at psychologically difficult moments that impeded us mounting our usual response. It certainly sounded like a bad day for the entire office.
It’s now important to produce a strong response against Leeds.
I’ve only seen the lowlights and your report seems to address perfectly the impression they convey.
There have been and will continue to be much better days. Our squad hasn’t suddenly lost its capability to perform at the very highest level. I’m sure that MA8 will use this performance and the result to drive home a series of messages around the subject of ‘Never fookin’ happening again’. The video replays and Mikel’s observations on them in the ‘learning chamber’ will not make pleasant viewing for anyone who was on the field in red and white today.
Onward.
I can only base my comments on the despondent message from my son, who was at the Amex.
At least it’s stopped all the bollocks about going invincible.
Onwards and upwards. No doubt there will be demands for Arteta to be sacked. Hey ho.
I was trying to make sure my son hadn’t thrown himself under the train on the way home. He responded saying it wasn’t nearly as bad as Wolves away or Bournemouth last season, or the Etihad where we thought we had blown it.
Wise words from a young man. Dave Faber would have approved.
I’ve steeled myself to watch a large part of the game and what MOTD will show. CER has described it very fairly and knowing Countryman Junior his analysis will be fair and balanced .
What I would say is that this is a very good Brighton side . I dislike Fabian Hürzeler as much as the next man, if that man is Donald Trump but that was an exceptional performance given that a lot of the squad had to come from two down at ManUre on Wednesday .Their duel success, second ball recovery and their intensity was remarkable and frankly 5-0 would not have been an unfair scoreline.
Sadly I predict that given yellow cards can be reviewed , Declan will be upgraded to a straight red for a very petulant challenge at the end .
One of Arteta’s many great qualities is his ability to get his teams to bounce back after a setback. However he won’t see most of the squad for the best part of three weeks and we have a challenging game against Leeds then. This just proved that the comment that there are no easy games in the Premier League is not a cliche .
We will bounce back but one observation that concerns me is that away from home Tzolis is half the player he is at home . We are missing Trossard . Let’s hope it’s something we can sort .
Thanks CER – succinct and the right tone for a performance that stunk the house out. A good wake up call that has come so early in the season and with another 33 league games to go absolutely there’s no need to push the panic button – just yet.
Everyone and every team deserve/s a cold shower every now and again to stop them getting too big for their boots. Prematch I thought that if our midfield played to its full potential we might squeeze a win out but sometimes fine margins do go against us and that happened all over the field. That midfield looked far better on paper than it did on the pitch. What I have seen on TV doesn’t show any lack of effort, just flawed execution of usually silky passing and movement and defenders failing to deliver their usual high standards. All three goals were preventable. Havertz’s hapless late effort when one-on-one with the keeper pretty much summed up our day.
As I read about Brighton in preparation for the preview I realised just how much Hürzeler would be desperate to win this game to match the achievements of his predecessors, his frustration at the results last season (hence his post-match hissy fit last March) and the concurrence of Brighton’s 125th anniversary celebrations. Hürzeler clearly hugely motivated his players who looked far more driven than the Arsenal players and appeared to win most duels. We walked like innocents into a trap with targets on our backs of being newly-crowned champions and were ambushed by an opposition inspired by the chips on their coach’s shoulders..
CER@3: Generously said, and agreed.
Only two shots on target tells its own story. We were second best on the day.
C100@9: I caught a glimpse of C100 Jnr on the telly. He looked concerned but otherwise fine.
Thanks CER, quick and succinct indeed. Personally, I agree with Ned that the fine margins went against us and it was a bad time to play them on the back of three
away games on the trot, their shooting hot, anniversary game, sense of injustice
Etc etc. We’ve been good at nicking the points with dodgy team performances but
there was no one at all to step up this time. Been a long time since we took a three goal beating and no doubt individuals will be singled out, MA slated, and all the usual suspects rounded up. Hopefully it will sting and the boys will respond accordingly.
Harsh but fair, and mercifully short. Cheers, CER.
I would just add that there were maybe 10 or so minutes a little before their first when I thought we were coming back strongly into the game and I was hopefuly, while you didn’t mention the truly great opportunity that should have seen us equalise just before they got their second, but overall yes, good description of the match.
Before their third I was thinking: our corners haven’t been so great lately, it would be just typical if we conceded from one….
We were even more abject after thhat and could easily have conceded more.
Rice’s last, literally, kick, of the game wasn’t pretty either, thankfully just a yellow.
And indeed, Spu*s provided the safety comfort blanket before we kicked off, but that was more or less expected so no consolation.
Now three weeks to hope our internationals don’t get injured, then get the machine properly restarted.
Was it the accumulation of 3 away trips – 2 of which were very tough, a virus that hit the squad, or something behind the scenes that caused yesterday’s performance
It seemed odd to me that Arteta didn’t utilise more of the squad after the run of games we’ve had but it sounds like those who eventually came on were no better.
Bit of a worrying thought on yesterday – I think we were all expecting fatigue to kick in at some stage after an exhausting season and a World Cup, especially as the situation, for many of the players, was made worse by the injuries that plagued us one way or the other almost all the way through.
Rice and Saka especially suffered through the World Cup and then returned to training early so as not to miss any games.
Maybe that fatigue has kicked in. The Spanish players also went all the way to the World Cup final.
Rice’s kick/ trip of that Brighton player at the end of the game was quite uncharacteristic and smacked of a frustrated and very tired player.
Even David Raya made some very sloppy / tired mistakes yesterday which is most unusual for him.
Raya did not play (or not much) in the World Cup, and while he’s been brilliant so far before yesterday, he’s not had much to do during most matches this season so far.
His mistakes were uncharacteristic, but I’d say if he was tired it would be because of a bad night’s sleep rather than overplaying.
Maybe Arteta’s ‘we will simulate the worst situations with travel to have them prepared’ tactics are not all that great. :-p
Sure, but all those Spanish players still had to train and be match ready in case.
I don’t know if the accumulated fatigue is behind the performance or not, but something affected a lot of them all at once.
Fair point, Trev. Some credit has to go to Brighton’s relentless high press, but most of our players certainly looked off yesterday indeed.
Trev @17.
I think you are right to point out the impact of three away games in succession . To have four games of that intensity away from home is quite unusual , especially so early in the season , albeit we played largely a shadow squad at Ipswich .
Yesterday Brighton were excellent, we started poorly , we looked very tired and we had been on the road for eleven days .
It’s hard to draw comparative conclusions. C130y have much more attacking potential than we do but it’s incredible to concede three goals at home to Sunderland . At this stage I think we will see the title competed for by C130y ( unless they get struck with their deserved penalty ) – if they were innocent don’t you think that would have been announced by now? , Liverpool and both Brighton and Brentford look set for very successful seasons but there is a very long way to go.
Thank you CER for a succinct and incisive report!
It is only human nature to miss the things that we don’t have – so I accept my impressions may reflect that inherent state of mind. I thought we missed (a) in defense composure and control in possession under pressure (b) in attack a pacy outlet against high press.
We have been playing well enough to not have noticed the absence of Wilo, but he brings in so much quality and calmness that his absence cannot really remain unnoticed and unexploited for long.
Gabi Martinelli — for all his lack of end product in the PL and the plateauing of his skills — offered a genuine outlet against high line. Neither Saka nor Tzolis (who I think has been excellent for us, with a sharpness in decision and movements that’s very valuable) has that pace, and likely Madueke is the only one in this team who is fast enough. Maybe Max? It’s definitely a gap in the current attacking setup that sooner or later we will need to find a way to address. This is why Theo for all his inconsistency and limitations could still be very effective. Most teams won’t play high line against us, but when they do we need genuinely fast counterattacking outlets which we no longer have.
The collective collapse in quality and control isn’t unprecedented. In a busy season there would always be a few matches, especially away, when we will come up against spirited quality opponents who will outplay us that day. We had matches like that last year and some of those we won on the basis of defensive resilience and a few moments of quality. Yesterday could have been like that. The fact that it wasn’t may actually be a blessing in disguise. I won’t be surprised if we start a match again this season as the second best in every aspect in the first 10 odd minutes. I will be very very surprised if we don’t then fix it quickly and turn the performance around.
The GHF Predictathon leaderboard for Matchweek 5 has been posted — and the first five-week form guide of the season.
You know where to find them…
Thanks Ned – the usual prompt, excellent work 🙏🏻
Cheers, Trev. The monks are a well-oiled machine, well, well-oiled, at least.
Quite separately, it turns out that ‘collective team collapse’ is a thing. It occurs when “multiple players in a sports team experience a sudden and extreme underperformance within a game and are unable to return to their initial performance level”. Which sounds like Saturday at the Amex. There is a body of academic literature on it (just Google ‘collective team collapse’ to find examples). While I am not sure any of the research pinpoints what triggers the triggers of a collective team collapse, it does seem to affect the most elite teams in particular. Some combination of pressures and expectations blocks the behaviours, decisions, composure and collective structure that normally let a team perform at the highest level, and the effect is instantly contagious throughout the side.
@24, Ned,
Early days would appear to reflect quite well the wisdom of taking a flyer on an ‘unlikely, but possible’ arrangement of teams at the end (or for that matter at any stage) of the PL title chase just to add some spice to proceedings.
Cheers Ned. Have to admit the new angular form guide graphics make everything look different (slightly more chaotic?).
Ollie@28: Your aesthetic eye is sharp. The monks have had to revert to old-school connecting the dots with straight lines as the graphing tool that drew the curvy form guide is no longer available.
Granit Xhaka is a very naughty boy
But I wasn’t in the least surprised
Yeah, saw that, Matt, had no idea. Potential 5-year jail sentence apparently?
(I see it doesn’t say anything about potential sentence in the BBC article, but it said so in the Equipe one I read a couple of hours earlier).
The ultimate victimless crime.
Switzerland is an unusual country . I never quite adjusted to some of the cantonal laws which were in some cases quite draconian.
My friend who lived near Zug had a note pushed through his door reminding him it was against the cantonal bye laws to have a shower after 10 pm. He was later reminded he could not his grass on Sunday .
This is potentially more serious but I suspect he will receive a heavy fine . Jail is out of the question
Declan has pulled out of the England squad because of an unspecified injury.
He has probably come down with a severe case of being knackered. This, from the BBC, is insane:
Rice played 69 games for Arsenal and England last season. But he did much of it carrying a hamstring injury which affected him at the World Cup. Despite this, he has played in 549 minutes of the 630 possible for Arsenal this term.
TTG@35: I trust the missing verb in your sentence starting, ‘He was later reminded’, was ‘mow’ and not ‘shower on’.
Many municipalities on this side of the pond restrict homeowners’ use of gas- and diesel-powered landscaping equipment, such as leaf blowers, and ban commercial grass cutting on Sundays in a laudable effort to preserve the tranquillity of the day of rest.
I have always thought the defining characteristic of Switzerland is that you are never more than 30 mins away from spending money. Hike up a mountain, and someone is waiting at the top to sell you hot chocolate.
As Harry Lime said about Switzerland in The Third Man “500 years of peace and what did they give us? The cuckoo clock.”
Ned@36- The BBC in terms of news has become unwatchable/unlistenable. The gap between what and how they report and reality is increasingly large.
@38 😂 but Harry Lime wasn’t the most reliable of advisers!
Declan himself seems to think his schedule is tenable but even
the most durable have some sort of breaking point I would have
thought and I was very glad he pulled out of the England squad.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>