Feed on
Posts
Comments

The Great Divide

Over the last year I have been chronicling the modern rivalry between Arsenal and Tottenham in the Gooner. Despite my obvious bias as an Arsenal fan of sixty eight years standing, I tried to look as dispassionately as possible at the way the two clubs have developed. Someone of my age would view the rivalry very differently to anyone under forty who would have grown up with a general perception that Arsenal rule the roost in North London.

But, go back to 1961 and the picture was very different. Tottenham completed the  first modern double that year and after winning the cup again in 1962 they went on to become the first English club to win a European trophy when they won the Cup Winners Cup in 1963. For the first ten years of my football supporting life, Spurs held sway over Arsenal, winning the FA Cup three times in the sixties. Arsenal completed their own double in 1971, having won their first European trophy the year before. All this is, of course, detailed in my history in recent Gooners but talking to Layth we felt it would be good to look at the recent developments and try to place that in a wider context to sum up the relative success of the two clubs, as it’s hard to hold the story in your head with instalments several weeks apart! 

So this is an attempt to summarise where we are now and how we got there. This is the roll of honour of the two clubs up until the end of last season. 

Head-to-head by competition:

* League championships: Arsenal 14 – 2 Tottenham

* FA Cups: Arsenal 14 – 8 Tottenham

* League Cups: Tottenham 4 – 2 Arsenal

* European trophies: Tottenham 4 – 2 Arsenal

If we look at head to head matches the figures are: 

* Total matches: 213

* Arsenal wins: 91

* Tottenham Hotspur wins: 67

* Draws: 55 

Reflecting back to my earlier point, if you had done the head to head analysis in the mid 1970s the figures were almost equal. In the last fifty years Arsenal have pulled away from Tottenham. It began under George Graham who presided over four Arsenal away victories in 1987 (all by two goals to one), at White Hart Lane, in the space of nine months.

Arsene Wenger was even worse news for Spurs fans.

His overall record in all competitions was:

* Played: 52

* Won: 23

* Drawn: 20

* Lost: 9

* Win percentage: 44.2%

* Unbeaten: 43 of 52 matches (83%). 

Since Arteta has been in charge at Arsenal, his record is: 

* Played: 13

* Won: 9

* Drawn: 1

* Lost: 3

* Goals scored: 27

* Goals conceded: 17

* Win percentage: 69.2%. 

Historical context is always important when considering football. As a South London schoolboy in the early sixties, I knew very few Arsenal fans and the glamour sides supported by boys at my school were Manchester United and Spurs. Spurs played elegant football and made big, glamorous signings like Mackay, Greaves, England, Mullery,  Gilzean and Venables. Arsenal lingered below them in the sixties but our double season in 1971 was the springboard for a different pecking order although the mid seventies saw both clubs in the doldrums and Spurs were even relegated in 1976-7. 

Arsenal sprang back to life in the late seventies, winning the FA Cup in 1979 during  a sequence of three finals in a row, and losing a European final. One of my great memories was going to White Hart Lane just before Christmas 1978 and seeing a Brady-inspired Arsenal thrash Spurs 5-0. It was a Spurs side that contained their two World Cup winners and Glenn Hoddle and they soon recovered, winning FA Cups in 1981 and 1982, followed later by success in Europe.

But there, the histories begin to diverge. Under Graham, Arsenal won two league titles, two domestic trophies and the European Cup Winners Cup. Spurs last won the FA Cup in 1991 having beaten us 3-1 in the semi-final on that dark April day. But since then, we have won the FA Cup nine times. Spurs haven’t won the League since 1961. Arsenal have won it seven times since. Spurs have a slightly better history in Europe but neither club has won the Champions League and Tottenham’s last European trophy, the Europa League, is very much a second tier trophy. In terms of appearances in the major European competition, Arsenal have competed 24 times to Tottenham’s 8. 

There has been a litany of modern Spurs managers, too many to name them all but Pleat, Venables, Vilas-Boas,  Jol, Gross, Redknapp, Ramos, Graham, Hoddle, Conte, Mourinho, Postecoglou, Frank and now De Zerbi come to mind.

In the same period Arsenal have had Howe, Graham, Rioch, Wenger, Emery and Arteta. In all that time only one Spurs manager has overseen a period of Spurs dominance and put St.Totteringham into retreat – Mauricio Pochettino. Under Pochettino, Spurs briefly overtook Arsenal and reached a high water mark of a Champions League final. The duo of Kane and Son upfront were Arsenal’s  Nemesis in the way that Charlie Nicholas and Robert Pires always seemed to be regular scorers for Arsenal in North London derbies. Less than six months after playing the Champions League final in Madrid, Pochettino was gone, having, so many Spurs fans claimed, in that immortal phrase, ‘taken the club as far as he could‘. The night he conjured in Amsterdam to take Tottenham to the final stands as the most dramatic night in their history and, despite occasional Champions League qualifications since, the club has struggled for equilibrium since that heady achievement.

Arsenal moved to the Emirates Stadium in 2006. They have played twenty North London derbies there and lost once. Tottenham moved to the quite breathtaking New White Hart Lane stadium in 2019. There have been seven North London derbies there, of which Arsenal have won the last four. It is perhaps worth considering the stadia and their impact on the two clubs. 

Arsenal bit the bullet and moved to the Emirates in the midst of a hugely successful period in the mid-noughties. It cost them a lot of their best players and restricted their ability to buy others and it took them a long time to challenge again for major honours. In the last twelve years, they have won the league, four FA Cups, recorded four second place league finishes and reached the Champions League Final for the second time in 2026.

Tottenham have been able to build a state of the art stadium that is probably unequalled in Europe but filled it with a team that has finished 17th two seasons running and that only won three home games last season. The Europa League success in 2025 was a huge moment for the club but has hardly proved a foundation for moving forward. Tottenham fans have proudly asserted their right to be a Top Six club and in terms of financial wherewithal that is undoubtedly true but in playing terms domestically, one FA Cup in the last 35 years and no league title in 65 years doesn’t attest to a football powerhouse.

Arsenal’s fortunes have fluctuated significantly in the last forty years but since the start of the 1986–87 season when George Graham became the manager, Arsenal have finished outside the top six just twice in 2020 and 2021. Since  the start of the 1986–87 season, Tottenham Hotspur have finished outside the top six twenty-five times. That statistic brutally sums up the difference…and the distance between the clubs.

The early weeks of the new season have been an absolute disaster for Tottenham. In their last game before the break they scored their first goals of the season albeit in a losing endeavour to Villa. They have no wins this season and only two points, and the De Zerbi era looks eerily familiar to the Postecoglou and Frank eras. Arsenal’s uncharacteristic capitulation to Brighton in their last league game before the interlull was the only game they have failed to win this season. 

One final thought is to look at the club mottos. Arsenal’ s ‘ Victoria Concordia Crescit’  celebrates victory through harmony and in recent times the harmony and unity of purpose, albeit it in a very challenging environment, shines through. Spurs have a motto ‘Audere est Facere’ – to dare is to do. I must confess it has always rather irritated me because it seems to mean nothing. I think it is supposed to represent a high risk, high achieving enterprise but the Tottenham of Daniel Levy was never that and last season after his departure the club was, frankly, a shambles. Hope springs eternal in football. A bright new manager, many new, ostensibly interesting signings and a club reset for Spurs may see them reverse the decline of recent seasons, but they have a massive job to do to gain bragging rights in North London.

61 Drinks to “The Great Divide”

  1. 1
    ClockEndRider says:

    Nice, and timely, reminder of the evolution of the two clubs over the last 60 years, TTG. I particularly liked the reference to the 0-5 slaughtering of Sp*rs in December ’78. Who can forget the great John Motson’s exclamation after Brady had robbed Peter Taylor on the edge of their box and curled that delicious outside-of-the-left shot into their net – “Look at that, ohh look at that…what a goal by Brady!”” The hairs on the back of my next are standing up….
    Indulge yourselves by watching again the highlights and seeing what an absolute genius Brady was.

    Happy days…

  2. 2
    North Bank Ned says:

    Thanks for an excellent read, TTG, that provides chapter and verse for what we instinctively know: North London is red.

  3. 3
    North Bank Ned says:

    CER@1: Thanks for that clip. Lovely to see that Brady goal again. What a hit. Happy days indeed, with the haircuts as dodgy as I remember them.

    A curious footnote about the neighbour’s hapless keeper that day, Mark Kendall. In this final senior game, a Welsh Premier League match, his son, Lee, was in goal for the opposition.

  4. 4
    bt8 says:

    Mind the gap, indeed. As a matter of fact I plan to do just that on a regular and uninterrupted basis from now to kingdom come. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  5. 5
    TTG says:

    Thanks for those kind words and for that super clip CER. That is one of the most memorable moments of my Arsenal supporting life . I remember watching it back with my Dad on MOTD , Christmas lights blinking , two cigars and brandies in hand, after the slight anxiety I always suffered watching Arsenal at White Hart Lane and had experienced that day standing on the Shelf as our goals went in .
    One slight correction is that under George Graham we won three domestic Cups . George is the only Arsenal manager to have won the League Cup .

  6. 6
    Trev says:

    Thanks TTG – excellent perspectives on what the press in particular are always itching to jump on as a “power shift in north London “ if the Spuds ever win a game against us or spend a couple of weeks above us in the league table. Power shift my Arsenal.

  7. 7
    Bathgooner says:

    An excellent and well detailed retrospective of the mutual relationship of two clubs with very different trajectories currently. Your account of the 1960’s explains why so many of the sports media hacks of our generation, some sadly no longer with us, viewed the Arsenal through Lilywhite lenses. Long may the current disparity persist, although, as we know too well, ownership failings, poor managerial appointments and poor signings, if compounded, can quickly change things. It’s important to enjoy the good times because without a lot of careful nurturing, hard work and, possibly most importantly, luck, they don’t last forever.

  8. 8
    North Bank Ned says:

    Bath@7: Never a truer word said.

  9. 9
    North Bank Ned says:

    BBC saying that Arteta contract extension is now a done deal. The report is skimpy on terms, saying just that it will give him more money (duh!) and keep him at the club to at least 2029.

  10. 10
    ClockEndRider says:

    Ned@9 – as you say, very light in details. Hopefully it fir linger than 2029 as well. Hopefully the dotcom will confirm tomorrow.

  11. 11
    ClockEndRider says:

    Dear Lord my typing is getting worse. Hopefully you get the gist.

  12. 12
    JML says:

    @1 CER, Thanks for the video. Have watched it a good few times in recent years…It never gets boring!!
    How many years did we get out of singing ‘We won five nil at the lane’ ? (to the tune of ‘Sailing’ by Rod Stewart, for the younger readers here)

  13. 13
    ClockEndRider says:

    JML@12 –
    “It was easy
    It was easy
    It was easy
    At the Lane”!

  14. 14
    ClockEndRider says:

    Unfortunately I was at the Lane in 1983 when they returned the favour! That was not a fun return journey down that crappy High Road….

  15. 15
    JML says:

    Was oblivious to that result….in more ways than one.
    Got the call from ‘Sex and drugs and rock and roll’ in ’79 ( at 16) and my limited budget was henceforth redirected…

  16. 16
    OsakaMatt says:

    JML@15 ditto 😂
    Though I remember the Brady / Sunderland game well….

    Fine piece thanks TTG, I vaguely remember us being dead level
    in terms of victories and the absolute disintegration of the spuds
    reputation since then has been a real pleasure. We should ship over
    a crate of straws to their deluded support every season.

  17. 17
    ClockEndRider says:

    It appears that JML and OM are the twin George Bests of GHF – “where did it all go wrong?”!
    As long the limited budget wasn’t wasted…!

  18. 18
    TTG says:

    CER @17
    Indeed. I hope Miss World was one of the distractions .
    I’m glad my drinks of choice then were Horlicks and Dandelion and Burdock although I would have a sweet sherry as I listened to the velvet tones of Max Bygraves . A clean, monastic life has done me no harm

  19. 19
    ClockEndRider says:

    TTG@18 – Methinks he doth protest too much!

  20. 20
    BtM says:

    Superb read, TTG accompanied by some entertaining comments.

    I believe the more complete translation of ‘Audere est Facere’ is ‘to dare is to do, innit, Rodney’. I recall reading those exact words on the side of Del Trotter’s yellow three wheeler.

  21. 21
    Bathgooner says:

    I’m shocked! Shocked, I tell you!

    While I was leading a saintly life in the frozen north, healing the sick and labouring for worthy causes, albeit, betimes, familiarising myself with the flavours of grape and grain, some Holics were succumbing to pleasures that displaced our great club in their priorities.

    I’m shocked!

  22. 22
    North Bank Ned says:

    No good deed goes unpunished, Bath.

  23. 23
    bathgooner says:

    Surely, we are all delighted that MA8 and the Board have reached agreement on a contract through to the end of the decade? The benefits of this decision are nicely detailed by Keenos:

    Most important Arsenal news this century

    In my opinion, the most important decision was actually that of deciding to appoint MA8 in the first place despite him never ever having been a head coach and with the knowledge that many, if not most, assistant coaches/managers prove inadequate as head coaches/managers. A big thank to that appointment committee.

  24. 24
    Ollie says:

    All I know is they are bottom of the league.
    Cheers TTG!

  25. 25
    Ollie says:

    Judging from these drinks (and a fair few others, to be honest), I’d say your saintly life has at the very least led you to repeatedly uttering wise words…Dr Jones.

  26. 26
    North Bank Ned says:

    Bath@23: Thanks for that link. The last sentence is the money shot for me:

    The most important thing isn’t simply getting back to the top. It’s building something strong enough to stay there.

    That is the definition of an elite club.

  27. 27
    North Bank Ned says:

    To follow up on @26: staying at the top is hard. Of the 51 teams to have played in the Premier League, just six have been ever-present: Chelsea, Everton, Liverpool, Man U, the neighbours and ourselves.

  28. 28
    ClockEndRider says:

    Ned@27- of course football wasn’t invented in 1992. Am I right in thinking only 1 team has been ever-present for more than 100 years in the top flight?

  29. 29
    ClockEndRider says:

    Regardless of 27 @ 28 above, as I wrote in a piece over the summer, the next step is to turn the club into a genuine elite club. It very much feels as though the combination of this manager and this ownership is determined so to do. That would be a significant step forward.

  30. 30
  31. 31
    ClockEndRider says:

    Oops…wrong one…

    “Big Club”? My Arsenal!

  32. 32
    North Bank Ned says:

    CER@28: You are indeed correct. 101 consecutive seasons and counting. That is more than twice as many seasons of top-flight football as the chickens on a basketball at the wrong end of the Seven Sisters Road have managed in total.

    You drew a distinction in ‘Big Club?’ between elite and ultra-elite clubs. Putting words in your mouth, the ultra-elite are the elite clubs that are persistently elite, not elite in patches. We are somewhere between the two at this point, but with the opportunity to step up.

  33. 33
    TTG says:

    It is worth casting our minds back to the summer and the pursuit, ultimately fruitless , of Vinicius Junior . Vini Jr is a genuine world superstar and if he had joined he might have become the most ‘ famous’ player in modern times to play for Arsenal.
    It might be pointed out that I scoffed at the idea. I didn’t scoff at our efforts to sign him but I was convinced his entourage were playing us and so, it probably, appeared to be .
    But the point about our pursuit was that it was credible – from our point of view because we are English champions just edged out in the Champions League Final and from his point of view because he might have been able to claim that in playing terms Arsenal are an upgrade on Real Madrid at the present time ( we certainly were two seasons ago ) and he could create genuine leverage on Florentino Perez by appearing ready to go to Arsenal. Had we not been a credible departure point Real would not have been forced back to the table and to largely capitulate to his demands .
    That wouldn’t have happened in Emery’s time or in the last ten years or so of Wenger’s. But Arteta has elevated us to new heights and we are potentially able to claim we are close to being one of the elite clubs of Europe . That is, as Keenos rightly says largely down to Arteta .

  34. 34
    bathgooner says:

    Further to TTG @33, I saw a piece earlier today – sadly I can no longer find it, but I didn’t imagine it – which was from Spain and stated that Vini Jr’s friends were convinced that he was going to join Arsenal until the day he signed a new contract with Rea, which recent events may have caused him to regret. This fits with the rumours that the Arsenal hierarchy believed he was going to join us until the day before he signed that contract. I suspect that Berta is hot on the trail of a comparable acquisition.

  35. 35
  36. 36
    Bathgooner says:

    It’s probably the source. The piece I saw was a short statement in English.

  37. 37
    OsakaMatt says:

    @17 the budget was often limited but as for wasted…..
    I can’t remember….

    TTG, Bath 😂😂 I hope virtue was its own reward.

    Great news on MA8, though I wasn’t too worried as I think
    he thinks the same as most of us here – still work to
    be done.

  38. 38
    bathgooner says:

    This is a very good analysis of how Brighton beat us in the last game (£). Hurzeler may be a prick but he’s a pretty smart coach.

    https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7617405/2026/09/22/did-you-notice-brighton-press-arsenal/

  39. 39
    North Bank Ned says:

    Bath@38: Thanks for that link. It breaks down what we saw last Saturday in Brighton preventing us from establishing our usual control. I would guess that Arteta and his staff are spending the interlull devising ways to thwart any other club that tries to copy Herzeler’s pressing tactics. Once bitten, and so on

    This piece on Man City’s recruiting process is typical of recent BBC articles in leaving the reader with more questions than answers. Its interesting point, to my mind, was how City planned its team rebuilding two to three seasons out, and tried to offload its stars just as they passed their peak. I’m sure we do the same. Martinelli might well be a minor example. https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/articles/cm1wx51gyly5o

  40. 40
    bathgooner says:

    Interestingly, Charles Watts reports that Martinelli’s agent claimed that they had decided that he had reached a natural cusp and that it was time for a new project. Martinelli had allegedly received offers from Italy, Germany and some PL clubs and chose to join the biggest club in Asia because it offered an opportunity to ‘clear his head’.

  41. 41
    North Bank Ned says:

    A list of the Academy players on international duty this interlull. Somewhat of a shift to home nations’ call-ups compared to previous years.

    England under-20s: Andre Harriman-Annous & Khari Ranson
    England under-19s: Max Dowman & Ife Ibrahim
    England under-17s: Charlie Phillips, Mylo Bernard & Vincent Joseph
    Northern Ireland under-17s: Daniel McCarron
    Poland under-18s: Patrick Stachow
    Scotland under-19s: Callan Hamill
    Uganda under-17s: Isiah Matthews
    Wales under-19s: Axel Donczew

  42. 42
    North Bank Ned says:

    Bath@40: That sounds like a bit of post-hoc rationalisation; at very least, a meeting of minds.

  43. 43
  44. 44
    ecg says:

    And the first Arsenal casualty of the break is Havertz who lasted 30 minutes for Germany today.

  45. 45
    Trev says:

    Yes, but is he really injured ? (Asking for TalkSport, 5Live, Sky Sports – just to save them the bother)

  46. 46
    bathgooner says:

    Havertz crocked!

    Wouldn’t you just know that was going to happen?

    Hope Gyökeres finds his mojo.

  47. 47
    bathgooner says:

    A thought-provoking piece from Tim Stillman, though it picks some scabs off old wounds:

    Winning the league is hard, defending it harder still

  48. 48
    Trev says:

    I would start Merino ahead of Gyokeres if Havertz is injured. 1 in 2 strike rate,

  49. 49
    Countryman100 says:

    City found guilty of 114/115 charges. Ornstein is the source.

    https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7049721/2026/09/25/manchester-city-charges-verdict-premier-league/

  50. 50
    North Bank Ned says:

    Havertz’s injury is now being described as a ‘muscle strain’. He won’t be playing in Germany’s next game, and wouldn’t have played in their remaining two games in this interlull thanks to Klopp’s novel selection of two squads.

    Mike McDonald said last season that Big Vik wouldn’t come good until his second season in the PL. The Swede has to get the games if he is going to prove that assertion.

    But until then, a searching pass through the lines to…

  51. 51
    North Bank Ned says:

    …the back of the net apparently.

  52. 52
    North Bank Ned says:

    C100@49: I hope Ornstein’s reporting forces a long-overdue public confirmation by the PL of that finding. I wouldn’t be surprised to learn that the decision was leaked by some rightly disgruntled folk withnin other PL clubs to force just such a turn of events.

    However, the piece’s second sentence is deflating:

    The sanctions have not been decided, with all possibilities remaining on the table, and City are expected to appeal.

    As m’learned friends say, Justice delayed is justice denied.

  53. 53
    Countryman100 says:

    After these findings today, guilty on 114/115 charges, I’m so glad we thumped them by a seven point margin to win the league fair and square last season. With Pep. With their structure and roster after all the financial shenanigans. No one can say we only won because they were docked points.

  54. 54
    Countryman100 says:

    The charges are no longer “alleged”.

    Now let’s see them relegated to league 2 and stripped of all honours since 2009.

    And a five year transfer ban.

    Where’s that prat with the Arsenal water bottle now?

  55. 55
    TTG says:

    Don’t be deflated Ned
    I’m with C100
    The conviction genie is out of the bottle
    All of their ‘ achievements ‘ are permanently tarnished and the credibility of anything they achieve in the foreseeable future will be non- existent . They are blown to bits as a club
    They would be well advised not to appeal if they value what remains of their reputation ( having thought about that it’s nothing!) But continuing to drag this out as all of the clubs who have already built cases with their legal teams about what City have cost them will pile on
    They are the pariahs of English football

  56. 56
    Countryman100 says:

    Lance Armstrong is the exemplar here. In the years in which he won the Tour de France it now says “no trophy was awarded”. That’s what we should do.

  57. 57
    Bathgooner says:

    It’s the end of the beginning but not the beginning of the end. I expect another appeals dance around the Maypole.

    When Marseilles were proved to have cheated their way to the Ligue 1 title in 1992, they were stripped of the title, relegated and prevented from taking their CL place but PSG who finished second were not awarded the title. I suspect that will be the precedent applied.

    However this is a far worse and more extended piece of cheating, so the Conference League would be their appropriate location for next season. A boost for the coffers of some small clubs if the plastics still turn up to see them play in the real world.

  58. 58
    Ollie says:

    C100 @ 53 : Amen.
    Well in for the somewhat confused half-century, Ned.

  59. 59
    TTG says:

    We are going to publish an emergency piece on this later tonight .
    My C114y friends ( sadly I have some) believe the game is up. They are not wrong

  60. 60
    Countryman100 says:

    Bravo TTG and Bath! The whole of the football world is talking about this, we need to be too!

  61. 61
    Bathgooner says:

    >>>>>>>>>>>>>>